You are here

Coalition Letter to Governor Cuomo to Withdraw RD SGEIS

November 2, 2011

Honorable Andrew M. Cuomo
Governor of New York
The State Capital
Albany, NY 12224

Dear Governor Cuomo:

We, the undersigned, strongly support safeguarding the environment, public health, natural resources and scenic splendor of New York’s Catskills, Finger Lakes and Southern Tier regions. With that goal in mind, we request that you immediately withdraw the Marcellus Shale revised draft Supplemental Generic Environmental Impact Statement (RD SGEIS) in order to resolve the fundamental shortcomings documented herein.

There is a de facto moratorium on horizontal hydrofracturing in New York’s Marcellus Shale pending adoption of a Final SGEIS. The Department of Environmental Conservation’s (DEC) 2009 Draft SGEIS received such withering criticism that Governor Paterson signed Executive Order No. 41 requiring DEC to: “make such revisions to the Draft SGEIS that are necessary to analyze comprehensively the environmental impacts associated with high-volume hydraulic fracturing combined with horizontal drilling, ensure that such impacts are appropriately avoided or mitigated …” On 1/1/11, you signed a “continuation” of that Order.

The RD SGEIS Must Be Withdrawn Due to DEC’s Failure to Fulfill Executive Order No. 41

DEC’s RD SGEIS fails to fulfill the mandate of Executive Order No. 41. First and foremost, it is based on the erroneous assertion that:

“No documented instances of groundwater contamination are recorded in the Department’s files from previous horizontal drilling or hydraulic fracturing projects in New York. No documented incidents of groundwater contamination in public water supply systems were reported by the NYSDOH central office and Rochester district office... References have been made to some reports of private well contamination in Chautauqua County in the 1980s that may be attributed to oil and gas drilling... The reported Chautauqua County incidents, the majority of which occurred in the 1980s and which pre-date the current casing and cementing practices and fresh water aquifer supplementary permit conditions, could not be substantiated because pre-drilling water quality testing was not conducted, improper tests were run which yielded inconclusive results and/or the incidents of alleged well contamination were not officially confirmed.”

This statement is factually incorrect and deliberately misleading. Hundreds of natural gas and oil drilling, hydrofracturing and related problems have reportedly impacted private water wells, homes and the environment in New York. Those problems are documented by DEC as well as health authorities in Chautauqua, Cattaraugus and Allegany counties.

Ferrugia’s “Well Documented” Drinking Water Problem “Seemingly Related to Gas Well Development”

For example, DEC is well aware that the Ferrugia family near Jamestown, NY has not been able to drink their well water since 2007 after a gas well was drilled approximately 300 feet from their home. Their water is so polluted that their veterinarian even warned them not to allow their dogs to drink the water. Chautauqua County Health authorities determined: “This is a well documented case showing drinking water impacts that are seemingly related to gas well development.” Yet, DEC has refused to assist this family.

The Ferrugia’s problem directly refutes the RD SGEIS assertions about gas drilling incidents in Chautauqua County because it: a) occurred relatively recently and is on-going; b) was not prevented by DEC regulatory safeguards or gas well drilling and production improvements; c) is documented by pre-drilling and post-drilling drinking water baseline testing and d) was confirmed by local health officials.

See an interview with Mr. David Ferrugia and extensive documents regarding his water well problem at: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0Ka0QJaKZ4s and http://www.toxicstargeting.com/node/7084

Dave Eddy’s Confirmed Drinking Water Contamination in Andover, NY

The Ferrugias are not the only New Yorkers who reportedly were impacted by inadequate regulation of gas drilling. Mr. Dave Eddy and his family experienced drinking water contamination and gas intrusion into their home, reportedly due to hydrofracturing of nearby gas wells. His water pollution was confirmed by the gas drilling firm. See: http://www.toxicstargeting.com/MarcellusShale/videos/andover_independenc... and http://www.toxicstargeting.com/MarcellusShale/documents/allegany_us_ener...

Recently Reported Natural Gas and Oil Spills Further Document DEC’s Regulatory Shortcomings

DEC's hazardous materials spills database identifies hundreds of on-going failures to clean up oil and gas drilling pollution impacts, including at least 72 recently reported natural gas and oil concerns. See: http://www.toxicstargeting.com/sites/default/files/pdfs/jamestown/group1... These problems further document DEC’s regulatory enforcement shortcomings. For example:

LITTLE WELL - EAST SULLIVANVILLE ROAD HORSEHEADS, NY, 6/23/2011: EQUIPMENT FAILURE – BRINE – 200 gallons. “APPROX 200 GALLONS OF BRINE WATER TO GRAVEL AT WELL SITE. THE SPILL WAS THE RESULT OF A LEAK IN A PORTABLE STORAGE TANK.” Meets Cleanup Standards: NO.

STOSCHEK WELL - 49 BECKHORN HOLLOW ROAD VAN ETTEN, NY, 3/8/2010: EQUIPMENT FAILURE – BRINE – 756 gallons. “VALVE ON THE BRINE TANK FROZE AND BROKE. ALLOWING ABOUT 18 BARRELS OF BRINE TO LEAK OUT.” Meets Cleanup Standards: NO.

POYSA WELL #E1 - 61 BRIGGS HILL ROAD VAN ETTEN, NY, 4/8/2011: EQUIPMENT FAILURE – BRINE – 693 gallons. “Valve on brine tank at closed-in well froze and cracked allowing a release of 16.5 barrels of fairly fresh brine.” Meets Cleanup Standards: NO.

GRUNERT NO. 1 WELL – SOUTH MAIN STREET EXTENSION [?], NY NO ZIP PROVIDED, 6/1/2011: EQUIPMENT FAILURE – CRUDE OIL – 200 gallons. “LEAKING ABOVEGROUND PLASTIC TANK THAT’S INVOLVED WITH GAS WELL.” Meets Cleanup Standards: NO.

TUSCARORA BRINE APPLICATION – TOWN OF TUSCARORA DIRT ROADS TUSCARORA, NY, 6/21/2010: DELIBERATE – BRINE. “Caller states Town is using brine from gas wells to control dust on dirt roads and are applying it way too heavy causing runoff to ditches and streams. Also concerned about his well and what might be in the brine.” Meets Cleanup Standards: NO.

A total of more than 400 historic natural gas and oil concerns are documented by DEC and local health authorities. These concerns refute DEC’s assertion that gas extraction problems do not exist: http://www.toxicstargeting.com/sites/default/files/pdfs/jamestown/CCDOH-... and http://www.toxicstargeting.com/MarcellusShale/drilling_spills_profiles

At Least 16 Additional Reasons Why the RD SGEIS Must be Immediately Withdrawn

In addition to the regulatory enforcement problems noted above, the RD SGEIS must be immediately withdrawn and sent back to the drawing board because it does not resolve key concerns voiced by Region 2 of the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), academic researchers, citizens and local officials. It fails to:

1. Afford equal health protection to all New Yorkers living above the Marcellus Shale formation. The RD SGEIS proposes to ban Marcellus Shale horizontal hydrofracturing in the New York City and Syracuse watersheds and above State Lands and primary aquifers (at least temporarily). If horizontal hydrofracturing is not allowed in those areas, it cannot be considered “safe” for other areas of New York.

2. Resolve mortgage lending problems associated with gas leasing. The RD SGEIS ignores gas leasing impacts on mortgage lending documented by lenders, including lender reluctance to secure mortgage loans with properties with gas leases; concerns about property valuation and marketability; "set-back" issues regarding the sale of mortgage loans on the "secondary" market and potential voiding of title insurance. See: http://www.toxicstargeting.com/MarcellusShale/alerts/natural-gas-leasing...

3. Assess horizontal hydrofracturing conducted at the same well pad in both Marcellus Shale and underlying Utica Shale. The RD SGEIS does not address this potential practice, but EPA views it as a matter of grave concern. See: http://toxicstargeting.com/sites/default/files/pdfs/map-email-responses-...

4. Ban gas drilling wastewaters from being discharged into Publicly Owned Treatment Works designed for sanitary waste or adopt strict pretreatment standards. POTWs are not designed, constructed or maintained to remove or break down the high levels of Total Dissolved Solids (TDS), toxic petroleum constituents and radionuclides documented in gas drilling wastewater. EPA reports that shale gas extraction wastewater contaminants may "'pass through' the POTW, causing the POTW to violate its permit, cause 'interference' with the POTW's operation, or contamination of biosolids..." Pennysylvania has banned this practice. EPA has just begun the process of adopting national pretreatment standards for gas drilling wastewaters. See: http://www.toxicstargeting.com/MarcellusShale/documents/letters/2011/06/...

5. Ban toxic gas drilling wastewater from being recycled as hydrofracturing or drilling fluid. Gas drilling wastewaters, including "flowback" as well as "brine" or "produced water," are currently exempted from “GA” effluent limitations designed to safeguard drinking water drawn from the ground in New York. The RD SGEIS fails to eliminate this exemption even though gas drilling wastewater is documented to contain up to 413,000 parts per million of TDS, 72,600 parts per billion of Total Petroleum Hydrocarbons in the diesel range as well as benzene up to 660 parts per billion. Those pollutant concentrations would vastly exceed applicable GA effluent limitations. For example, benzene is only allowed at one part per billion in permitted groundwater discharges.

6. Ban land-spreading of toxic gas drilling wastewaters. DEC allows gas drilling brine to be spread on land for dust control, roadbed stabilization and melting ice and snow. EPA recommended: "A program must be implemented to properly manage the elevated radionuclide concentrations in the brine to protect the worker health, public health, and the environment." The practice of gas drilling wastewater spreading must be halted.

7. Resolve inadequate DEC staffing problems. The infamous memo that caused DEC Commissioner Grannis to be fired noted: "Many of our programs are hanging by a thread. The public would be shocked to learn how thin we are in many areas;" The memo further noted: "While the risks to human health have already increased due to cuts to certain environmental quality programs, and especially to enforcement activities related to pollution sources, further cuts would result in unacceptable risks to New Yorkers and unacceptable liability for New York State government (emphasis added)." Governor Cuomo cut DEC’s budget in 2011. See: http://www.toxicstargeting.com/sites/default/files/dec_dobletter_Grannis...

8. Identify New York areas prone to higher seismic activity and propose measures to prevent earthquakes potentially associated with horizontal hydrofracturing. EPA reported that: "The dSGEIS notes that the State of New York is fairly active seismically. EPA recommends that NYSDEC limit the number of wells in areas of higher seismic activity, or require additional protective measures and monitoring." See: http://www.toxicstargeting.com/MarcellusShale/documents/comments/2009/31...

9. Adopt comprehensive radionuclide standards to safeguard gas drilling workers, public health and the environment. EPA notes that "radionuclide concentrations specified in the DSGEIS represent elevated radionuclide concentrations and need to be handled, managed, and disposed of appropriately to avoid unnecessary exposure to workers, the public, and the environment." EPA also determined that "such concentrations are considered elevated and may pose unacceptable human health risk mainly via external exposure, inhalation of radon and thoron decay products, and to some degree via inadvertent ingestion."

10. Resolve EPA concerns about inadequate protection of Ecosystems and Wildlife. EPA reported: "This section [7.4] is incomplete, and does not account for the changes in the ecosystems in New York State since the preparation of the 1992 GEIS. For example, more animals and plants are on federal and state endangered species lists, habitats of all kinds are more fragmented, invasive species have impacted existing animal and plant populations, and climate change has impacted plant and animal ranges and migrations.”

11. Assess "cumulative impacts" on a comprehensive basis. EPA notes that it is "concerned that cumulative and indirect impacts need to be more thoroughly discussed in the dSGEIS. Even with its generic format, the EIS should discuss the impacts that may result from past, present, and reasonably foreseeable future projects as well as those impacts associated with drilling and hydrofracturing that may occur later in time and/or further from the immediate project site."

12. Update the 1992 GEIS. EPA notes that it is "concerned that over the past 17 years since the 1992 GElS was written, the 'existing' environment and conditions in New York State have changed sufficiently that using the information from that report as a baseline for the dSGEIS will not take into account the cumulative impacts from habitat fragmentation, population increase, and climate change that may have occurred during that time."

13. Require compliance with a critical EPA policy change regarding air quality assessment. Shortly after the draft SGEIS was released on 9/30/09, EPA adopted a major new policy regarding New Source Review (NSR) and Title V permitting programs pursuant to the Clean Air Act. This reversed the EPA policy in effect when the draft SGEIS was prepared. The new policy changes the requirements for "source aggregation" for air permitting programs. According to a DEC Powerpoint slide: "Since level of aggregation must be case by case, SGEIS cannot provide definitive answers (emphasis added)." See: http://www.nytimes.com/gwire/2009/10/14/14greenwire-epa-tosses-bush-era-... and http://toxicstargeting.com/sites/default/files/pdfs/powerpoint_foil-4pg.pdf

14. Eliminate DEC’s current hazardous waste regulatory exemption for gas drilling wastes and impose strict liability for cleaning up gas drilling pollution hazards.

15. Require the New York State Department of Health to share co-lead agency status with DEC and assess health impacts on a comprehensive basis.

16. Require immediate disclosure of uncontrolled gas drilling pollution releases, establish a dedicated fund to remediate gas drilling hazards and require gas drilling firms to provide financial surety for remediating problems by posting bonds or providing insurance coverage.

Conclusion

The RD SGEIS fails to provide a meaningful plan to safeguard New York from the irreparable harm that could be caused by the vast industrialization associated with Marcellus Shale horizontal hydrofracturing. Unless and until DEC resolves its regulatory enforcement problems and addresses the additional concerns documented herein, New York’s de facto moratorium on horizontal hydrofracturing in Marcellus Shale must not be lifted.

We trust that you will find our request self-explanatory. Thank you for your consideration. We look forward to your prompt reply.

Very truly yours,

Total Signatory Count: 22949

Rob Friedman
217 East 26th St
New York, NY
diana projansky
198 east 7th street #12
new york, ny
Maria Rivera
166 Beard Street
Brooklyn, NY
JOSH NUDELL
711 LOWELL AVENUE
NEW HYDE PARK, NY
Karen Myer
65 Northwoods Road
Saugerties, NY
Ellen Carter
159 High St.
Phoenicia, NY
Robbee Fian
484 west 43rd St
NYC, NY
Helen Wadsworth
4883 Scottsburg Road
Groveland, NY
Ellen Reese
49 Starin Avenue
Buffalo, New York
Deborah Collins
15 Summit Ave, Apt 1
Albany, New York
Steve LeVine
71 Ocean Parkway- Apt. 1D
Brooklyn, NY
nina sweet
11 Riverside Drive - #9WE
New York, NY
George Koenig
51 Bronson St.
Oswego, NY
Timothy Biel
250 East Houston Street #12G
New York, NY
Daniel Salisbury
49 Sheraton Dr
Ithaca, NY
Frank McLoughlin
14 Tanglewood Road
Albany, New York
Kahlil Goodwyn
30 Montrose Ave. #22Q
Brooklyn, NY
Thomas D. Herzog
2 Woodway, P.O. Box 403
South Salem, NY
James Luscher
384 Phillips Hill Road
New City, NY
Marc Brown
10-17 Jackson Ave. # 5C
Long Island City, NY
Miranda Marchese
627-629 Commonwealth Ave.
Boston, Massachusetts
Rachel Kurtz
East River Drive
Lake Luzerne, NY
jeff levine
po box 295
mount kisco, ny
Jason Coscia
245 Grand Street
Brooklyn, NY
Leslie Miller
66 Barrow Street
New York, NY
Elizabeth Whitehouse
81 East Third Street
Corning, NY
Charles Zekus
151 Depeyster st
Sleepy Hollow, Ny
Mary Mottler
225 River ST
Rochester, NY
Katy Bray
PO Box 408
Rosendale, NY
Alison Carb Sussman
400 E. 20th St.
New York, NY
Janice Fellegara
492 Henry St
Brooklyn, NY
Eva Kittay
152 Homestead Trail
White Lake, NY
Christine Schuch
140 East 2nd Street Apt 3B
Brooklyn, New York
James C. King
po box 73
Cadyville, NY
Abigail Place
10 Pinecrest Drive
Cortland, NY
Susan Schmidt
110 S. Ronda Road
McHenry, IL
mike drake
2107 borden ave 5th floor
kic, ny
Patricia Reinhardt
56 Oakdale Drive
Rochester, NY
Ryan Thompson
52 S. Genesee St
Fillmore, NY
Hope Carr
358 85th Street
Brooklyn, NY
Brian Seibert
145 22nd St #1
Brooklyn, NY
Abby Williams
205 Clinton Avenue
Brooklyn, New York
Patricia Abbenda
263 Scotch Bush Rd
Pattersonville, NY
susan deane-miller
126 hooker
poughkeepsie, NY
Rachel Cullenen
23 Sheraton Dr.
Ithaca, NY
Sarah Vogwill
250 N 6th Street
Brooklyn, NY
Egizio Panetti
156 Spring St.
New York, NY
Robert Muller
231 Stevens Rd
Edmeston, NY
carol thomas
400 East 52nd Street, # 8D
new york, ny
Roxeann Hock
30 Victory St.
Middletown, NY
Rosemary Lattimer
723 TiticusRd
North Salem, NY
Bright Limm
144-33 79th Ave 2J
Flushing, New York
james gross
109 genung circle
ithaca, new york
Mike Brooks
4109 North Rd
Geneseo, NY
Lydia Pettis
358 W King Rd
Ithaca, NY
Ken Kocses
144A Newell St
Brooklyn, NY
Frank Cefalo
5 Tudor City Place
New York, NY
David Bartlem
315 Gates Avenue #5-S
Brooklyn, New York
monica plimack
200 east end ave. 4e
new york, New York
Frank Alguire
110 Bushendorf Road
Ravena, NY
Jeremy Peterson
315 West 23rd St.
New York, NY
Charles Levin
2350 Lafayette Ave
Bronx, NY
Donald Myers
933 Haverstraw Rd.
Suffern, NY
Jane Smith
10 October Circle
Lagrangeville, NY
Megan O'Neill
96 Avenue C #2R
New York, NY
Aracy Winter
1075 Park Ave. Apt. 11A
New York, NY
Eric Horowitz
187 seeley st
Brooklyn, NY
Giovanni Garcia
4108 47th St
Sunnyside, NY
melissa zavala
34-20 78th St
Jackson Heights, NY
Oriel Eaton
520 Gair St.
Piermont, NY
Sean Mahony
531 East 20th Street
New York, NY
Gary Donelian
6 Warren Pl
Saugerties, NY
Sue Wolfsie
8 Jennifer Court
New Paltz, NY
Marianne Delaney
504 Bedford Center Road
Bedford, NY
Karen Shatzkin
258 West 99th Street, Apt 5
New York, NY
Nancy Berggren
99 Grove St.
Ballston Spa, NY
David Makepeace
2 Summers St
Livonia, ny
Thomas Wilson
8 Stryker Lane
Clinton, NY
Rita Tobachnik
47 Westwood Road
Yonkers, NY
ERICA Bray
2454 24th street
Astoria, Ny
Elizabeth Segal
33 Fairview Ave
Tarrytown, NY
Leslie Jacobs
80 Brook Rd
Pittsford, NY
Maggie Joralemon
5657 Route 97
Narrowsburg, New York
Joel Boyer
314 Mulberry St.
Rochester, NY
Charles Dale
99-40 63rd Road, Apt.14L
Rego Park, NY
Nob Ichishita
109 Branford Rd
Rochester, NY
Sarah Sills
78 Prospect Park West
Brooklyn, NY
Natasha Hopkinson
60 West 23rd St
NY, NY
Brian Mattiske
57 Celeste Drive
Rensselaer, NY
Corey Tarreto
829 Elmwood Ave
Buffalo, NY
Peter Moock
185 Murray Avenue
Larchmont, NY
Robert Defrin
P.O. Box 58
Amenia, NY
Dr Michelle Handwerker
50 Shultis Farm Rd.
Bearsville, NY
Constance Jeske
2023 Burr Ave.
Bronx, NY
Eva Yachnes
720 West End Ave
New York, NY
Vicki Universal
5109 Booher Hill Road
Geneseo, New York
Peter Saul
2341 21st street
Astoria, NY
lisa buon
155 neelytown road
montgomery, new york
Joseph Quirk
147 Avenue A #2R
New York, NY
Nat Katin-Borland
171 Clermont Ave.
Brooklyn, NY
Julie Sergel
6595 Maples Rd.
Ellicottville, NY
Eugene DeZarn
3965 Spring Road East
West Sparta, NY
rosalind McKevitt
318 West Olive Street
Long Beach, NY
Jovon Everett
44 Pinehurst Ave. #3D
New York, NY
grace fontaine
180 Meserole St
Brooklyn, NY
Michael F.
215 Adams Street
Brooklyn, New York
Henrietta Foster
27 Charter Oaks Dr.
Pittsford, NY
Edward rollins
207 east 4 street
new york, NY
Trudy Fitzsimmons
49 Fairhaven Blvd.
Woodbury , New York
Gemma Burgio
430 Ocean Parkway 4N
Brooklyn, NY
T G Vath Gertin
Campus Dr
Rochester, Ny
Karen Matsu Greenberg
922 County Road 94
Fremont Center, NY
Beverly Rice
3 East 85 Street
NY, NY
Ann Marie O'Reilly
5745 Federal Rd.
Conesus, NY
Laurel Ullyette
97 Franklin Street
Auburn, NY
Ruth Byington
3607 172 St.
Flushing, New York
Anne Ohman
44 Heathen Hill Rd.
Franklin, NY
James Nowack
PO Box 895
Marlboro, NY
John Bianca
511 Craig St.
Syracuse, NY
Laura Haines
POBox 310
Rensselaerville, New York
Dara Price
44 S. Monsey Rd.
Airmont, NY
Michael Prete
326 Sackett St 5B
New York, NY
Miriana Demas
333 E 92 St
New York, NY
nicole basso
340 haven ave 3!
ny, ny
Mara and Robert Bannard
27 West 96 Street
New York, NY
Daniela Elefteriadis
147 Sunset Ave
Farmingdale, NY
John Putnam
67-67 Burns Street Apt. 7P
Forest Hills, NY
Arnold Hammerschlag
1663 10th Avenue, 2nd Floor
Brooklyn, NY
Susan O'Brien
7783 Bainbridge Dr.
Liverpool, NY
Christina Donahue
94 Camp Adventure Road
Kerhonkson, NY
Kevin Cannon
207 East 37th Street
New York, New York
Marika Straw
711 E. Boldt Way, SPC 1419
Appleton, WI
Kinnan O'Connell
81 Willow Ave
Larchmont, NY
Robert Hayden
4601 Limeledge Road
Marcellus, New York
Melinda Little
118 Shepard Ave.
Saranac Lake, NY
Gareth Hinds
205 Pinehurst Ave, Apt 5G
New York, NY
Trix Niernberger
518 Potterhill Rd
Petersburgh, NY
Kevin Bott
203 Tolley Bldg
Syracuse, NY
Louise Warren
98 Van Cortlandt Park South-1F
Bronx, NY, NY
Rich Greco
400 Lafayette Street
NY, NY
Alan Scott
119 Pacific St.
Brooklyn, NY
Julianna Egner
25 Mercer Street
New York, NY
Peter Unterweger
5 hanna Lane #1
Beacon, New York
Barbara Nelson
340 Haven Ave
New York city, NY
D.C. Anderson
112 S. Jacqueline St.
New Windsor, NY
Katherine James
29-49 168th St
Flushing, NY
Stephen Morse
248 Elizabeth St
New York, NY
Andrea Ackerman
109 West 26th Street
New York, NY
Lenora Champagne
3 Horatio St.
NY, NY
Bill DesJardin
5074 Holley Byron Rd
Hollay, NY
Karen Gold Sherman
14 Bayeau Road
New Rochelle, NY
Kenneth Kirshenbaum
100 David's Way
Bedford Hills, New York
Margaret Shair
54 Boulevard
Suffern, NY
Rudolph Ripp
33 Sherman Avenue
Staten Island, New York
Joanne Cehovin
6 pebble hill road north
Dewitt, Ny
Anthony Dhandari
83-32 168 Place
Jamaica, NY
Patricia Battaglia
155 Floverton St.
Rochester, NY
Sean Nevins
261 Ontario St.
Wilson, NY
Marianne Cohen
531 East 88th St.
New York, NY
Steve Shulman
685 Academy St
New York, NY
Ann Brameier
318 W. 14th St.
New York, NY
Roger Schneier
143 Lakeshore Drive
Copake, NY
Carver Lee
222 W. 20th St. #1
New York, NY
Jeanne Heifetz
28 Sterling Place
Brooklyn, NY
Aaron Crozier
267 Clifton Place
Brooklyn, NY
Robert Dattola
1000 Cayuga Heights Rd
Ithaca, NY
Dustin Brauneck
35 Hamilton Place, #207
New York, NY
Paul Winkler
253 Prospect Pl
Brooklyn, NY
Colleen Griffin
30 West 63rd
New York, New York
Jeanpierre Caramanica
6 Prescott Place
Hastings on Hudson, NY
Caroline Rule
755 West End Avenue
New York, New York
David Bosch
W4
New York, NY
Roy Murphy
291 Eighth Street
Brooklyn, NY
Nancy Finton
310 Cumberland St
Brooklyn, NY
Edward Cerullo
2 Montague Terrace
Brooklyn, NY
Julianne Lutz Warren
50 West 77th Street 6M
New York, New York
suzanne gangemi
1924 Penfield Rd
Penfield, NY
Olivia May
126 College Avenue
Poughkeepsie, NY
Howard Petlack
1823 Stonehaven Drive
Boynton Beach, FL
Michael Goodman
145 Hicks Street, Apt. B28
Brooklyn, New York
Tom Germain
519 Franklin Street
Watertown, New York
Ashleigh Imus
110 West Marshall Street
Ithaca, New York
James Cooper
25-17 18 ST
Astoria, NY
Dave McCoy
3635 Bayview
Keuka Park, NY
Maria Luisa Cipriano
6601 Broadway Apt. 2I
Bronx, NY
Sharon Chopping
34 Cackletown Rd
Narrowsburg, NY
Arthur Nazarian
423 Lincoln Place Apt 9
Brooklyn, New York
d gavril
286 6th st
brooklyn, ny
natalie bartone
430 south franklin street
watkins glen, new york
Cara Kulwicki
202 East Squire Dr. Apt. 6
Rochester, New York
roberta baker
198 woodward ave
buffalo, ny
emily lippincott
1075 dean street
brooklyn, ny
Roberta Perell
89 Lakeview Dr.
Tomkins Cove, New York
Maxim Kolbowski-Frampton
415 Grand St.
New York, NY
Alan Karp
6838 Yelowstone Blvd
Forest Hills, NY
Lisa McCabe
31 Wren Field Lane
Pittsford , NY
Jean Rincon
474 West 238 ST
Bronx, New York
Sidney Trubowitz
1225 Park Ave
New York, NY
Alex Rothe
17 Sycamore Ave
Hillsdale, New Jersey
Anne Fisher
5657 State Route 97
Narrowsburg, NY
Louise Lassen
391 Union Street
Brooklyn, NY
Robert Loconto
30 Tango Lane
Carmel, NY
Charles wITTMAN
68 Stuart Ave
Amityville, NY
Karen Schifano
264 East Broadway
New York, New York
BArbara Dick
65 Corning Blvd.
Corning, NY
Paula Weld-Cary
35 Monterey Parkway
Rochester , New York
Lynn Herring
5 falls crossing
woodstock, NY
Richard Grover
2 Railroad Ave
Canton, NY
Betty Marton
5 Moonwatcher Place
New Paltz, NY
Stephanie Hutchinson
75 Owasco St., #2
Auburn, NY
Orlando R Reyes Sr
651 West 171 Street 57
New York, New York
Irene Fizer
203 West 98th Street
NYC, NY
Ethan Goodman
158 Fawn Hill Road
Tuxedo, NY
David Zung
378 Warburton Avenue
Hastings on Hudson, NY
Joseph Konig
266 Washington Avenue, C - 18
Brooklyn, NY City, New York
Leslie Bender
64 Plains Rd
New Platz, NY
William Farrell
12 N Lorna Lane
Airmont, NY
Kathy Burpee
6 High Street
Cold Spring, NY
Jay Hubisz
1545 Congdon Lane
Cortland, NY
aylin o
11 madison ave
new york, ny
Edgar Tobachnik
47 Westwood Road
Yonkers, NY
Andrea Russell
Clinton avenue
brooklyn, ny
robert braun
248 6th ave
Brooklyn, ny
Warren Bacon
497 Ouaquaga Road
Binghamton, NY
Marcia Zach
867 Meigs St
Rochester, NY
Amy King
533B Cold Spring Road
Laurel Hollow, NY
Kenneth Thomas
100 LaSalle St., Apt. 21D
New York, NY
Barbara Milrod
525 East 68 Street
New York, NY
r rcammisa
NY
Tarrytown, NY
Carl Foner
125 Boerum Place
Brooklyn, NY
Thomas Keane
PO Box 418
Catskill, New York
Janet Connor
370 S. Mountain Rd.
New City, New York
Brett Nelson
185 Forest Ave.
Buffalo, NY
Shelly Friedland
107 West 86 St
New York, NY
Marc Masciandaro
114 Troutman Street #209
Brooklyn, NY
Steven Bard
28 King St., #24
New York, NY
Granzo Daniela
23 N. Manheim Blvd.
New Paltz, NY
Katherine Selby
14 Eagleshead Road
Ithaca, NY
Kevin Khoury
316 N. Bellinger St.
Herkimer, NY
Jeanne Loysen
56 Lanark Crescent
Rochester, NY
Diana Quick
252 16th Street
Brooklyn, New York
Natalie Van Dorn
28 Charles Road
East Patchogue, New York
judith vorreuter
402 East 10th Street #1A
New York, NY
Donald Mcneil
106 College Ave
Poughkeepsie, NY
Lorien House
158 Kiswick St.
Staten Island, New York
David Cohn
33 Parkmeadow Dr
Pittsford, NY
Rachel Blank
203 17th St. Apt. 8
Brooklyn, New York
Jon Tehel
31 diamond st
brooklyn, ny
Danielle Benz
361 Forest Lane
Smithtown, NY
John O'Neill Jr.
15 colgate dr
smithtown, NY
Reynaldo Rodrigues
152 Vanderbilt Avenue
Brooklyn, New York
dennis hedges
375 old rte 209
hurley, ny
Rosalie Vespa
77 Carpenter Avenue
Mount Kisco, New York
Susan Gustafson
427 W 51
New York, NY
Dana Donadio
142 East 98th Street, #10
New York, New York
Chris Kibler
21 west st apt. 25A
New York, NY
Ann Stevens
6373 East River Road
West Henrietta, NY
Edward Butler
36 E. 69th St.
New York, NY
John Markowitz
151 West 86 Street
New York, NY
Rose Bonanno
52 Conant VAlley Road
Pound Ridge, NY
Daniel Elster
378 Feronia Way
Rutherford, NJ
Joseph Sackman III
68 Elm St
Hicksville, NY
Daniel Coughlin
114 Ridge Street #4F
New York, New York
Oliver Trager
56 Windsor Place
Brooklyn, NY
Sally Apfelbaum
454 East 18th Street
NYC, NY
Scott Wegener
311 Hart Ave
Staten Island, New York
David Barker
720 Weeks St.
Jamestown, New York
John Pumilio
378 Frank Road
Hamilton, New York
Melissa Wu
21 West Street
New York, New York
Warren Holman
135 West 96th Street
New York, Ny
Clare Miflin
44 Court St., Tower C
Brooklyn, NY
John Cardoni
131 avenue b ny ny 10009
new york, ny
Lee frisari
794 Dekalb Ave
Brooklyn, NY
dana mandel
8842 rte 90
king ferry, ny
Laura Esther Wolfson
244 Riverside Drive apt 5E
New York City, NY
Donald Stathm
581 Rathbun Hill Rd
East Meredith, New York
Sandra Greer
381 7th Street
Brooklyn, NY
Miriam Paeslack
3 Berkley Place
Buffalo, NY
Edward Temple
422 8TH Street
Brooklyn, New York
Mary Lyon
311 E. 10th St.
New York, NY
Liane Onish
140 Riverside Drive, Apt. 1L
New York, NY
Doreen Tiernan
142 Meehan Road
Mechanicville, NY
Jessica Bennett
200 Washington st
Troy, NY
Teri Stratford
8 Elm St.
Walton, NY
Aleta Pahl
14 Miller Road Apt 203
Rhinebeck, NY
Bernard Goldray
3980 Orloff Ave
Bronx, NY
Eric Liner
12 Hollister Road
Freeville, NY
Elaine Gotham
5145 Blodgett Rd
Naples, NY
Malley Heinlein
195 Hill Road
Kingston, NY
Irwin Cantos
36 7th Avenue
Brooklyn, NY
dakota smith
#96
pearl river, ny
Nicholas Avallone
202 Washington Ave.
Saugerties, NY
Valerie McAndrews
350 E 87th St, Apt B3
New York, NY
Eric Kaufman
23 Turtlepond Ln
Bedford, NY
Anthony Pellegrini
3516 Old Vestal Road
Vestal, NY
Kamilla Talbot
87 Summit Street #4
Brooklyn, NY
Gabriel Abate
259 Washington Ave
Brentwood, NY
Lois and Michael Esmay
17 Van Houten St.
Upper Nyack, NY
Albert Ahronheim
222 E. 80th Street
New York, NY
Katherine Korten
237 west 109 street #1A
New York, NY
Ellen Diamond
345 East 93rd Street, Apt 8C
New York, NY
Mary Lou Krueger
1050 Winona Blvd
Rochester, New York
David Goldstein
4904 Beach Reservation
Brooklyn, NEW YORK
Christopher Andreola
PO Box 336
Hurleyville, NY
Irene Scalise
3 Sherrill Ln
New Hartford, NY
Wayne Jarvis
8402 Quadrant Lane
Baldwinsville, NY
Joe Bailey
PO Box 325
Olcott Beach, NY
Gloria Seff
737 Park Ave.
New York, New York
Richard Mendes
30 Peter's Lane
Pound Ridge, NY
Loretta Neuhaus
261-11 West Street
Mount Kisco, NY
Bill Kalatsky
511 6th ave # 342
NY , NY
Bretagne O'Neill
67 Old Albany Post Road
Rhinebeck, NY
Jessica Zeccardi
Division street
Waterford, Ny
Beverly Ferguson
Alexander Lane
Croton on Hudson, New York
David Smolen
43 Beacon St.
Beacon, NY
John Fadden
1462 County Route 60, Onchiota, NY 12989
Onchiota, NY
Jeroen De Schrijver
361 Clinton Avenue
Brooklyn, NY - New York
lee ingraham
108 upperville back rd
smyrna, NY
Lance Theroux
20 Royce Avenue
Middletown, New York
Carol Soto
315 W 102 St Apt 5D
New York , NY
Kathleen Massara
349 Manhattan Ave.
Brooklyn, NY
Michael Coleman
509 W 121st St Apt 211
New York, NY
John Carr
12 Cotswold Drive
Centerport, New York
Robert Wilson
508 2nd St.
LIVERPOOL, New York
Michele Matteo
150 West End AVenue
New York, New York
Terence Coughlin
10 Howard Ct
Staten Island, NY
Christine Speicher
PO Box 4
Obernburg, New York
Chris Pellicano
65 Church St
OWEGO, NY
Rachael Beard
West 154th Street
New York, New York
Malcolm Ingram
310 Cornwall Drive
De Witt, NY
Jonathan Rose
88-36 242nd Street
Bellerose, NY
Patton Sarley
294 White Hill Road
Hillsdale, New York
Andy White
2207 Forrest pointe Drive
East Greenbush, NY
Zintis Muiznieks
259 Schwartz Road
Callicoon, NY
Theodora Mix
76a maspeth ave
brooklyn, ny
Suzanne Timmer
20 Garden Place
Beacon, NY
Earl Morris
4608 Pines Brook Rd
Walton, NY
Amy Trompetter
413 Main St.
Rosendale, NY
Anita Sanchez
418 Merry Road
Amsterdam, NY
grant collier
p.o. box 513
roxbury, ny
Christopher McBride
322 E. 59th St. Apt 5C
New York, NY
Edgar Roberts
113 Glendale Road
Scarsdale, New York
Heather Worzel
198 Kalin Weber Road
Glen Spey, NY
Bill Redman
1503 Cobblestone Court
Middle Island, NY
Holly Anderson
2618 New Road
Bovina , New York
Cc Marcy Dwyer
22 Rocky Lane
Garrison, New York
Deborah Hale
910 Lake Road
Webster, NY
Sara Gast
Box 27
Bloomington, NY
Gareth Hougham
53 Old Albany Post Rd
Ossining, NY
adam rapa
4007 67th St
Woodside, NY
lemuel wade
524 lafayette ave
Brooklyn, New York
Mary Reynolds
175 Route 340
Sparkill, NY
Miriam Eusebio
533 3rd St #6
Brooklyn, NY
Neil Freson
26 Bitternell Lane
Henrietta, NY
Claire Walsh
185 Old Broadway
Hastings-on-Hudson, New York
Daniel J. Behm
3602 Case Rd.
Marietta, New York
Karen Moshier
POB 938
Dryden, NY
Brian Sechler
33 Gibbons Lane
New Paltz, NY
Steven Capozzola
1244 Route 212
Saugerties, NY
Lisa Nordstrom
151 Iceland Dr.
Huntington Station, NY
patricia luccardi
18 jones ave
chatham, ny
Kathleen Benedetti-Fisher
1 Englewood Pl
Albany, NY
keith Eisenstark
53 West 104th St.
New York, NY
Joan Ferrante
440 Riverside Drive
New York, NY
S. Etherton
504 E. 63rd Street
New York, NY
Robert H. Feuchter
175-20 Wexford Terrace ,Apt 11H,
Jamaica Estates,, N. Y.
David Bragin
78 Prospect Park West
Brooklyn,, NY
Doug Miller
23 Cottonwood Lane
Pittsford, NY
Nick masercola
621 W189th St, 5D
New York, New York
david benedetto
330 Maple ave. apt 29
Westbury, ny
Edith Borie
6 Hickory Hill Rd
New Paltz, New York
Jacalyn DeValue
1 Saxon Drive Alfred NY 14802
Alfred, New York
Adam Cresko
200 Washington St.
Troy, NY
Nancy Herbst
929 Summitville Drive
Webster, NY
Bill Abrams
200 e 84th st.
New York, NY
Bertha Kriegler
527 Plymouth ave
Schenectady, NY
Charles Shepherdson
1400 Washington Ave
Albany, NY
Diana Rocine
306 E 5th Street #23
New York, New York
James L. Richy
61 Maple Street
Scarsdale, NY
Sean Sweeney
197 Ski Run Rd
Bloomingburg, NY
Reynolds Mulero
1912 3rd Avenue #4B, New York, N.Y. 10029
New York, NY
Joseph Hennigan
1557 Redtail Lane
Skaneateles, NY
Bert Eisenstadt
285 clinton st.
brooklyn, ny
Anita Fortune
59 Livingston St
Brooklyn, NY
Cordelia Stevens
735 Kappock street apt. 3D
Bronx, New York
Kelly Loveless
105 Grand Street
Albany, NY
Linda Devin-Sheehan
1 Erland Road
Stony Brook, New York
Bruce Eisenbeil
230 East 48 Street, 6F
New York, NY
Helen Eisenbach
752 West End Avenue
NY, NY
Heather Henderson
405 W 118 St #62
New York, NY
Patricia Swanson
1394 Amherst St, Apt 7
Buffalo, NY
Keenan Witherspoon
137-40 242 Sr
Rosedale, NY
Sarah Quintal
44 Richmond Ave Apt 5
Buffalo, NY
Travis Rude
99 JOhn Street apt 1106
New York, NY
Maria Spinelli
24 Birch Crescent
Rochester, NY
Justin Holm
176 Kingsland Ave
Brooklyn, NY
Judith Gage
PO Box 4
Bovina Center, NY
isabelle hayes
pob 945
south fallsburg, new york
Charles Higgins
2807 Graffenburg Rd
New Hartford, NY
Glenn Jochum
1985 Main Road
Laurel, New York
Daniel Lipson
10 Holland Lane
New Paltz, New York
Norman Starr
511 West 232 St.
Bronx, NY
James Rubins
2 W 67th St
New York, NY
Merle Showers
401 Highgate Ave.
Buffalo, NY
Phil Carney
1887 N. Groveland Place
Eagle, ID
Reid Singer
225 East 74th St
New York, NY
Gary D. Byrd
47 Bennett Village Terr.
Buffalo, NY
Katherine Wessling
176 Thompson St.
New York, NY
Constantine Coutsoukes
166-19 25th Ave
Whitestone, ny
Adam Nadler
220 West 98 Street, apt. 4J
New York, NY
Mary Magnusson
127 Quaker Bridge Road
Croton on Hudson, NY
Ellen Korz
41 Helen Drive
Wappingers Falls, NY
Karen Sorensen
388 11th Street
Brooklyn, NY
Steven Alexander
RR3 Box 22-1
Dalton, PA
Greg Navarro
157 Claremont Ave
Montclair, NJ
David Nassi
257 Gold Street
Brooklyn, NY
Deborah Everett
406 Caton Ave.
Brooklyn, NY
Pamela Soscia
4458 Latimer Rd
Groveland, NY
Karisa Senavitis
1131 Myrtle Ave
Brooklyn, NY
Kimberly Paddock
3549 Brandy Bay Dr
Penn Yan, New York
Denise Cameron
4357 Vireo Avenue
Bronx, New York
Elizabeth Zuba
387 park place
brooklyn, NY
Mary Molloy
467 Auborn Avenue
Shirley, NY
Ray daSilva
311 East 85th Street -Gdn.
New York, NY
Michelle George
107 Houston St
Depew, NY
Donna Harness
P.O. Box 51
Fallsburg, NY
Joan Elliott
36 7th Avenue #4
Brooklyn, NY
deborah healy-seidlitz
76 cross river rd
pound ridge, nY
Eric Albert
459 State St
Brooklyn, NY
jackie Gagen
1900 Rose Hill Road
Skaneateles, New York
kathleen DeZarn
2522 Buttermilk Pike
Villa Hills, KY
James Coutsoukes
166-19 25th Ave
Whitestone, ny
Barbara Nordenberg
305 S. Lenox Ave.
E. Patchogue, NY
Charles Gates
425 Riverside Drive-6H
New York , NY
Christian Díaz
450 Circle Road, West Apartments III
Stony Brook, New York
Stephen Milarsky
317 West 107th St. #3B
New York, NY
Jessica Vacanti
851 Carroll Street
Brooklyn, NY
ned kavanagh
65 tahoe dr
rochester, ny
allen hori
9 silverfish road
barryville, ny
Sarah Whitney Snyder
447 Prospect Ave Apt 1
Buffalo, New York
Loula Coutsoukes
166-19 25th Ave
Whitestone, ny
pamela moffat
box 456
waccabuc, NY
dot morgan
1 Court Square, 232501 Jackson Avenue
Long Island , NY
Philip and Margaret Spiesz
8354 S. Canada Hill Rd.
Machias, NY
Richard Geisler
246 Laburnam Cres
Rochester, NY
frederic Levrat
265 E 7 Street #4
New York, NY
Susan Kiberd
70 Clinton Avenue
Dobbs Ferry, NY
William Thompson
400 Riverside Drive, Apt. 1C
New York, NY
Julia Sisson
9 Lagrange Ave
Poughkeepsie, NY
Jonathan Lloyd
2734 State Route 7
Valley Falls, NY
Lawrence Simms
200 East 32nd St.
New York, NY
Neil Bleifeld
405 West 48th Street, Apartment 5FE
New York, NY
Terrence Tiernan
142 Meehan Road
Mechanicville, N. Y.
Wendy Gross
21 Benson Ave
West Nyack, NY
Joseph Fort
2313 Vineyard Rd.
Romulus, NY
Richard Gottlieb
433 West 44th Street
New York, New York
Quinn Caya
1001 Lafayette Ave
Buffalo, NY
Christopher Menjivar
483 Ocean Parkway
Brooklyn, NY
Ashley Farrell
28 riverview terrace
smithtown, ny
Thomas Merwin
245 West 107th Street
New York, NY
Carlton (Tom) Kissner
377 Westchester Ave. 2-J
Port Chester, NY
Elliot Nesterman
3092 33 St.
Astoria, NY
C. A. Contarino
51 Lancaster St.
Lynbrook, NY
Michael Kniat
12 Dongan Place, #401
New York, NY
Adam Rabiner
10 Plaza St. East. Apt. 14H
Brooklyn, NY
Marguerite Noll
10 Ironstone Dr.
Rochester, NY
Sarah Craft
794 Carroll St
Brooklyn, New York
Bradley Lubin
649 Grand St. Apt 3
Brooklyn , NY
Bev Halligan
4157 Colonial Place
Hamburg, NY
Myrna de Cuba
30 Monroe St.
Massapequa Pk., New York
Jacqueline Alfo
24 Riviera Drive
Selden, NY
rich tobin
72 rensselaer dr
commack, ny
marilyn jeffery
501 pleasant st
manlius, ny
Adam Baran
260 Withers St. Apt 3R
Brooklyn, NY
H.Toni Norton
605 Pine Crest Road
Endicott, NY
Charles Conkling
22 Holley St.
Walton, New York
Russell Squire
1155 Park Avenue
New York, NY
Tom Athans
8801 Shore Rd. Apt. 5A-1est
Brooklyn, New York
Julie Metz
54 Sterling Place
Brooklyn, New York
Joanna Liao
347 West 44th St
New York, NY
Paige Harrison
215 West 90 Street, Apt 3A
New York, NY
Nicholas Sigman
40 West 116th Street, B1105
New York, NY
D smith
#96
nyack, ny
Meaghan Lee Callaghan
190 Camp Avenue
Merrick, NY
Douglas Kelban
2596 Grand Ave
Bellmore, N.Y.
Kate Mullen
33 Homestead Drive
Plattsburgh, NY
Treva Levine
8 Hunters Lane
Ithaca, NY
Renee Baum
6 Elm Street
Brooktondale, NY
Nicholas Polizzi
1329 Corona Street
Denver, CO
Gina Santonas
80 Jewel St
Brooklyn, NY
Marge Acosta
4 Harbor Park Court
Centerport, New York
Michael Flexner
206 Front Street Apt 6E
Brooklyn, NY
Errin Doyle
192 W. Tupper St.
Buffalo, NY
Kristina Bumphrey
791 Flushing Ave. #3L
Brooklyn, NY
Erik Tonnesen
342 East 8th St. #2i
New York, NY
Eric Leveau
541 W 113th street (6 D)
New York, NY
Joanna Roy
549 W. 123 St.
New York, NY
Fiona Dejardin
164 Main Street
Schenevus, NY
Rebecca Berlant
8A First Place
Brooklyn, NY
Regina Rosati
Continental Dr
Lockport , NY

Pages