You are here

Coalition Letter to Governor Cuomo to Withdraw RD SGEIS

November 2, 2011

Honorable Andrew M. Cuomo
Governor of New York
The State Capital
Albany, NY 12224

Dear Governor Cuomo:

We, the undersigned, strongly support safeguarding the environment, public health, natural resources and scenic splendor of New York’s Catskills, Finger Lakes and Southern Tier regions. With that goal in mind, we request that you immediately withdraw the Marcellus Shale revised draft Supplemental Generic Environmental Impact Statement (RD SGEIS) in order to resolve the fundamental shortcomings documented herein.

There is a de facto moratorium on horizontal hydrofracturing in New York’s Marcellus Shale pending adoption of a Final SGEIS. The Department of Environmental Conservation’s (DEC) 2009 Draft SGEIS received such withering criticism that Governor Paterson signed Executive Order No. 41 requiring DEC to: “make such revisions to the Draft SGEIS that are necessary to analyze comprehensively the environmental impacts associated with high-volume hydraulic fracturing combined with horizontal drilling, ensure that such impacts are appropriately avoided or mitigated …” On 1/1/11, you signed a “continuation” of that Order.

The RD SGEIS Must Be Withdrawn Due to DEC’s Failure to Fulfill Executive Order No. 41

DEC’s RD SGEIS fails to fulfill the mandate of Executive Order No. 41. First and foremost, it is based on the erroneous assertion that:

“No documented instances of groundwater contamination are recorded in the Department’s files from previous horizontal drilling or hydraulic fracturing projects in New York. No documented incidents of groundwater contamination in public water supply systems were reported by the NYSDOH central office and Rochester district office... References have been made to some reports of private well contamination in Chautauqua County in the 1980s that may be attributed to oil and gas drilling... The reported Chautauqua County incidents, the majority of which occurred in the 1980s and which pre-date the current casing and cementing practices and fresh water aquifer supplementary permit conditions, could not be substantiated because pre-drilling water quality testing was not conducted, improper tests were run which yielded inconclusive results and/or the incidents of alleged well contamination were not officially confirmed.”

This statement is factually incorrect and deliberately misleading. Hundreds of natural gas and oil drilling, hydrofracturing and related problems have reportedly impacted private water wells, homes and the environment in New York. Those problems are documented by DEC as well as health authorities in Chautauqua, Cattaraugus and Allegany counties.

Ferrugia’s “Well Documented” Drinking Water Problem “Seemingly Related to Gas Well Development”

For example, DEC is well aware that the Ferrugia family near Jamestown, NY has not been able to drink their well water since 2007 after a gas well was drilled approximately 300 feet from their home. Their water is so polluted that their veterinarian even warned them not to allow their dogs to drink the water. Chautauqua County Health authorities determined: “This is a well documented case showing drinking water impacts that are seemingly related to gas well development.” Yet, DEC has refused to assist this family.

The Ferrugia’s problem directly refutes the RD SGEIS assertions about gas drilling incidents in Chautauqua County because it: a) occurred relatively recently and is on-going; b) was not prevented by DEC regulatory safeguards or gas well drilling and production improvements; c) is documented by pre-drilling and post-drilling drinking water baseline testing and d) was confirmed by local health officials.

See an interview with Mr. David Ferrugia and extensive documents regarding his water well problem at: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0Ka0QJaKZ4s and http://www.toxicstargeting.com/node/7084

Dave Eddy’s Confirmed Drinking Water Contamination in Andover, NY

The Ferrugias are not the only New Yorkers who reportedly were impacted by inadequate regulation of gas drilling. Mr. Dave Eddy and his family experienced drinking water contamination and gas intrusion into their home, reportedly due to hydrofracturing of nearby gas wells. His water pollution was confirmed by the gas drilling firm. See: http://www.toxicstargeting.com/MarcellusShale/videos/andover_independenc... and http://www.toxicstargeting.com/MarcellusShale/documents/allegany_us_ener...

Recently Reported Natural Gas and Oil Spills Further Document DEC’s Regulatory Shortcomings

DEC's hazardous materials spills database identifies hundreds of on-going failures to clean up oil and gas drilling pollution impacts, including at least 72 recently reported natural gas and oil concerns. See: http://www.toxicstargeting.com/sites/default/files/pdfs/jamestown/group1... These problems further document DEC’s regulatory enforcement shortcomings. For example:

LITTLE WELL - EAST SULLIVANVILLE ROAD HORSEHEADS, NY, 6/23/2011: EQUIPMENT FAILURE – BRINE – 200 gallons. “APPROX 200 GALLONS OF BRINE WATER TO GRAVEL AT WELL SITE. THE SPILL WAS THE RESULT OF A LEAK IN A PORTABLE STORAGE TANK.” Meets Cleanup Standards: NO.

STOSCHEK WELL - 49 BECKHORN HOLLOW ROAD VAN ETTEN, NY, 3/8/2010: EQUIPMENT FAILURE – BRINE – 756 gallons. “VALVE ON THE BRINE TANK FROZE AND BROKE. ALLOWING ABOUT 18 BARRELS OF BRINE TO LEAK OUT.” Meets Cleanup Standards: NO.

POYSA WELL #E1 - 61 BRIGGS HILL ROAD VAN ETTEN, NY, 4/8/2011: EQUIPMENT FAILURE – BRINE – 693 gallons. “Valve on brine tank at closed-in well froze and cracked allowing a release of 16.5 barrels of fairly fresh brine.” Meets Cleanup Standards: NO.

GRUNERT NO. 1 WELL – SOUTH MAIN STREET EXTENSION [?], NY NO ZIP PROVIDED, 6/1/2011: EQUIPMENT FAILURE – CRUDE OIL – 200 gallons. “LEAKING ABOVEGROUND PLASTIC TANK THAT’S INVOLVED WITH GAS WELL.” Meets Cleanup Standards: NO.

TUSCARORA BRINE APPLICATION – TOWN OF TUSCARORA DIRT ROADS TUSCARORA, NY, 6/21/2010: DELIBERATE – BRINE. “Caller states Town is using brine from gas wells to control dust on dirt roads and are applying it way too heavy causing runoff to ditches and streams. Also concerned about his well and what might be in the brine.” Meets Cleanup Standards: NO.

A total of more than 400 historic natural gas and oil concerns are documented by DEC and local health authorities. These concerns refute DEC’s assertion that gas extraction problems do not exist: http://www.toxicstargeting.com/sites/default/files/pdfs/jamestown/CCDOH-... and http://www.toxicstargeting.com/MarcellusShale/drilling_spills_profiles

At Least 16 Additional Reasons Why the RD SGEIS Must be Immediately Withdrawn

In addition to the regulatory enforcement problems noted above, the RD SGEIS must be immediately withdrawn and sent back to the drawing board because it does not resolve key concerns voiced by Region 2 of the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), academic researchers, citizens and local officials. It fails to:

1. Afford equal health protection to all New Yorkers living above the Marcellus Shale formation. The RD SGEIS proposes to ban Marcellus Shale horizontal hydrofracturing in the New York City and Syracuse watersheds and above State Lands and primary aquifers (at least temporarily). If horizontal hydrofracturing is not allowed in those areas, it cannot be considered “safe” for other areas of New York.

2. Resolve mortgage lending problems associated with gas leasing. The RD SGEIS ignores gas leasing impacts on mortgage lending documented by lenders, including lender reluctance to secure mortgage loans with properties with gas leases; concerns about property valuation and marketability; "set-back" issues regarding the sale of mortgage loans on the "secondary" market and potential voiding of title insurance. See: http://www.toxicstargeting.com/MarcellusShale/alerts/natural-gas-leasing...

3. Assess horizontal hydrofracturing conducted at the same well pad in both Marcellus Shale and underlying Utica Shale. The RD SGEIS does not address this potential practice, but EPA views it as a matter of grave concern. See: http://toxicstargeting.com/sites/default/files/pdfs/map-email-responses-...

4. Ban gas drilling wastewaters from being discharged into Publicly Owned Treatment Works designed for sanitary waste or adopt strict pretreatment standards. POTWs are not designed, constructed or maintained to remove or break down the high levels of Total Dissolved Solids (TDS), toxic petroleum constituents and radionuclides documented in gas drilling wastewater. EPA reports that shale gas extraction wastewater contaminants may "'pass through' the POTW, causing the POTW to violate its permit, cause 'interference' with the POTW's operation, or contamination of biosolids..." Pennysylvania has banned this practice. EPA has just begun the process of adopting national pretreatment standards for gas drilling wastewaters. See: http://www.toxicstargeting.com/MarcellusShale/documents/letters/2011/06/...

5. Ban toxic gas drilling wastewater from being recycled as hydrofracturing or drilling fluid. Gas drilling wastewaters, including "flowback" as well as "brine" or "produced water," are currently exempted from “GA” effluent limitations designed to safeguard drinking water drawn from the ground in New York. The RD SGEIS fails to eliminate this exemption even though gas drilling wastewater is documented to contain up to 413,000 parts per million of TDS, 72,600 parts per billion of Total Petroleum Hydrocarbons in the diesel range as well as benzene up to 660 parts per billion. Those pollutant concentrations would vastly exceed applicable GA effluent limitations. For example, benzene is only allowed at one part per billion in permitted groundwater discharges.

6. Ban land-spreading of toxic gas drilling wastewaters. DEC allows gas drilling brine to be spread on land for dust control, roadbed stabilization and melting ice and snow. EPA recommended: "A program must be implemented to properly manage the elevated radionuclide concentrations in the brine to protect the worker health, public health, and the environment." The practice of gas drilling wastewater spreading must be halted.

7. Resolve inadequate DEC staffing problems. The infamous memo that caused DEC Commissioner Grannis to be fired noted: "Many of our programs are hanging by a thread. The public would be shocked to learn how thin we are in many areas;" The memo further noted: "While the risks to human health have already increased due to cuts to certain environmental quality programs, and especially to enforcement activities related to pollution sources, further cuts would result in unacceptable risks to New Yorkers and unacceptable liability for New York State government (emphasis added)." Governor Cuomo cut DEC’s budget in 2011. See: http://www.toxicstargeting.com/sites/default/files/dec_dobletter_Grannis...

8. Identify New York areas prone to higher seismic activity and propose measures to prevent earthquakes potentially associated with horizontal hydrofracturing. EPA reported that: "The dSGEIS notes that the State of New York is fairly active seismically. EPA recommends that NYSDEC limit the number of wells in areas of higher seismic activity, or require additional protective measures and monitoring." See: http://www.toxicstargeting.com/MarcellusShale/documents/comments/2009/31...

9. Adopt comprehensive radionuclide standards to safeguard gas drilling workers, public health and the environment. EPA notes that "radionuclide concentrations specified in the DSGEIS represent elevated radionuclide concentrations and need to be handled, managed, and disposed of appropriately to avoid unnecessary exposure to workers, the public, and the environment." EPA also determined that "such concentrations are considered elevated and may pose unacceptable human health risk mainly via external exposure, inhalation of radon and thoron decay products, and to some degree via inadvertent ingestion."

10. Resolve EPA concerns about inadequate protection of Ecosystems and Wildlife. EPA reported: "This section [7.4] is incomplete, and does not account for the changes in the ecosystems in New York State since the preparation of the 1992 GEIS. For example, more animals and plants are on federal and state endangered species lists, habitats of all kinds are more fragmented, invasive species have impacted existing animal and plant populations, and climate change has impacted plant and animal ranges and migrations.”

11. Assess "cumulative impacts" on a comprehensive basis. EPA notes that it is "concerned that cumulative and indirect impacts need to be more thoroughly discussed in the dSGEIS. Even with its generic format, the EIS should discuss the impacts that may result from past, present, and reasonably foreseeable future projects as well as those impacts associated with drilling and hydrofracturing that may occur later in time and/or further from the immediate project site."

12. Update the 1992 GEIS. EPA notes that it is "concerned that over the past 17 years since the 1992 GElS was written, the 'existing' environment and conditions in New York State have changed sufficiently that using the information from that report as a baseline for the dSGEIS will not take into account the cumulative impacts from habitat fragmentation, population increase, and climate change that may have occurred during that time."

13. Require compliance with a critical EPA policy change regarding air quality assessment. Shortly after the draft SGEIS was released on 9/30/09, EPA adopted a major new policy regarding New Source Review (NSR) and Title V permitting programs pursuant to the Clean Air Act. This reversed the EPA policy in effect when the draft SGEIS was prepared. The new policy changes the requirements for "source aggregation" for air permitting programs. According to a DEC Powerpoint slide: "Since level of aggregation must be case by case, SGEIS cannot provide definitive answers (emphasis added)." See: http://www.nytimes.com/gwire/2009/10/14/14greenwire-epa-tosses-bush-era-... and http://toxicstargeting.com/sites/default/files/pdfs/powerpoint_foil-4pg.pdf

14. Eliminate DEC’s current hazardous waste regulatory exemption for gas drilling wastes and impose strict liability for cleaning up gas drilling pollution hazards.

15. Require the New York State Department of Health to share co-lead agency status with DEC and assess health impacts on a comprehensive basis.

16. Require immediate disclosure of uncontrolled gas drilling pollution releases, establish a dedicated fund to remediate gas drilling hazards and require gas drilling firms to provide financial surety for remediating problems by posting bonds or providing insurance coverage.

Conclusion

The RD SGEIS fails to provide a meaningful plan to safeguard New York from the irreparable harm that could be caused by the vast industrialization associated with Marcellus Shale horizontal hydrofracturing. Unless and until DEC resolves its regulatory enforcement problems and addresses the additional concerns documented herein, New York’s de facto moratorium on horizontal hydrofracturing in Marcellus Shale must not be lifted.

We trust that you will find our request self-explanatory. Thank you for your consideration. We look forward to your prompt reply.

Very truly yours,

Total Signatory Count: 22949

Hier William
2423 Route 174
Marietta, NY
Robin Appel
po box 5
Upgon, NY
Robert Kuhn
125 Fifth Avenue 10F
Pelham, NY
Michael Schiano
40-137 W 4th St
Patchogue, NY
Jennifer Kietzman
4601 Fort Hamilton Pkwy
Brooklyn, NY
David Vanden-Eynden
130 West 25th Street
New York, NY
Linda Mehler
23 Terrace Place
Hicksville, NY
Howard Lichtman
152 River Street
Oneonta, NY
Tanya Pollard
541 8th St
Brooklyn, NY
Jill Ryan
3723 Burlingame Road
Cazenovia, NY
MARC TURNER
2119 SENECA DRIVE NORTH
MERRICK, NY
maya flamm
36 w. 96th st., apt.7
new york, NY
Carol De Angelo
535 Ashford Avenue
Ardsley, NY
Jessica Goodwin
10 Secor Rd
Scarsdale, NEW YORK
Andrew Axelrod
200 West 79th Street #8P
New York, NY
Susan Stulz
305 Riverside Dr, #3-D
New York, NY
henrietta statham
Road581 Rathbun Hill
East Meredith, NY
Melanie O'Hara
300 Union Street
Brooklyn, NY
Katherine Kelly
253 Bullock Rd.
Slingerlands, NY
Werner Mayer
26 Eklund Blvd
Nesconset, NY
Timothy Raymond
45-1/2 Marshall St
Rochester, NY
Patricia Carozzo
41-31 51 Street
Woodside, New York
Amelia Roberts
1180 Northrup Rd
Penfield, NY
John t sempowski Sempowski
7284 Maplewood Ave.
Lima, New york
Sharon Raynor
48 Lincoln Place
Ossining, NY
Sarah Louis
96 Liberty Street
New Baltimore, New York
donna blank
247 willow glen road
Red Hook, New York
Jalila Aissi
164 N 6th Street Apt 4
Brooklyn, New York
Penny Favale
8115 Miles Road
East Amherst, NY
Abby E.F.
1 College Circle
Geneseo, NY
Brien Sauchelli
697 President St.
Brooklyn, NY
Cindy Simon
2 Stonegate Road
Ossining, NY
Anne Donchin
5 Riverpointe Rd.
Hastings on Hudson, NY
William Good
1169 Highland Park Rd.
Schenectady, NY
Sam Liebowitz
392 CENTRAL PARK W
NEW YORK, NY
jeffrey ellenbeger
504 w 110th st #5-f
new york, ny
Ann Brennan
559 N. Greenbush Road
Blauvelt, NY
linda brecht-torn
7 torn hill road
bearsville, New York
Allan Ahearne
1660 CR 33
Cooperstown, NY
Deborah Bruce
7795 Vermont Hill Road
Holland, NY
Pax Whitfield
36-11 31st Ave., Apt. 1D
Astoria, NY
Juliet Neidish
35 West 92 St
New York, New York
Peter Berley
321 East 45 Street #4J
New York, New York
James Schwinn
315 Marion Street
Rochester, NY
Lynnr Lightowler-Buck
134 Nabob Row
Bainbridge, NY
Angus Watkins
2945 Butts Road
Ashville, NY
Justin France
Hasbrouck Apt
Ithaca, NY
N Lebwohl
Somerset Knoll
Brewster, ny
Ronnye Davies
199 5th Ave.
Brooklyn, NY
Matt Fortier
311 W. 97th St. Apt. #1-E
New York, NY
Margie Sabath
31 Chasewood Circle
Rochester, New York
Deborah Rubin
243 West 98 Street Apt. 6A
New York, New York
Mary Lou Schwartzberg
6705 Elm Beach Road
Ovid, NY
Alison Ogden
98 Morningside Ave
New York, NY
Jerome Hoffman
3786 Bedford Avenue
Brooklyn, New York
robert schoenberg
55 coutant road
circleville, new york
Arley Tapirian
203 Beach 77th Street
Arverne, New York
cyndi felker
PO BOX 537
SUGAR LOAF, NY
Anna Nicholls
2398 Brookview Drive
Hamilton, NY
Herbert Harwood
531 Main St
New York, NY
Hollis Milark
23 Roweland Ave.
Delmar, NY
Emily Weil
1117 Woods Rd.
Germantown, NY
MICHAEL INGRAM
97 UDSON TERRACE
YONKERS, NY
Thomas Costello
8 Winthrop Place
Ithaca, NY
Karen Goldsteen
2 Stern Drive
Port Jefferson, NY
Paul Thomason
424 West End Ave
New York, NY
Kathy Butterly
405 E. 13th St.
New York, NY
Drew Walsh
100 Haven Ave
New York, NY
Daniel Paul
6075 Exchange St
Newfane, NY
Barry Newman
304 W 117TH ST APT 7V
NEW YORK, NEW YORK
Bruce Markens
127 West 96th Street
New York, New York
Clare Piaget
1 Rockwell Place
Brooklyn, NY
Eddie Chan
257 Clinton St
New York, New York
Grady Best
309 East 108th Street #2H
NYC, NY
Andrea Goldhor
3 Farview Terr.
Airmont, New York
Randal Angiel
17 Angiel ane
Saugerties, NY
Jean Young
32 Harrison Dr
Larchmont, NY
Roy Whitford
27675 Water St
Chaumont, NY
Sara Margolis
154 President Street
Brooklyn, NY
Rebecca Tamez
228 E 26th St Apt 4d
New York, NY
Carl Mierek
34 Ashwood Ave
Whitesboro, NY
Donna Cohen
70 Duck Pond Rd
Stone Ridge, NY
Brent Hill
PO Box 182
Hammondsport, New York
mark emanatian
716 6 street
watervliet, ny
Robert and Margie Van Meter
275 Washington
Saratoga Springs, N Y
Brandon Holmes
179 Starr Street
Brooklyn, NY
Joseph DiLuzio
2332 15th street
Troy, NY
Linda Wheeler Reiss
16 Bayview CT
Manhasset, NY
Sally Rappeport
911 Union St.
Brooklyn, NY
Sally Wellinger
292 Fifth Street
Saint James, NY
Marsha Aronson
91 COLDENHAM RD
WALDEN, New York
Daniel Howe
108 Raup Rd.
Chatham, NY
Olga Cendroski
80-61 Lefferts Blvd.
Kew Gardens, NY
Michael Dougherty
37 Overlook Terrace #3G
New York, New York
Ben Mirling
121 Nelson Ave
Saratoga Springs, NY
James Mulder
28 Sachson Pl
Wappingers Falls, NY
Maryellen Whittington-couse
19 Quaker Street
Tillson, ny
Catherine Sentigar
97 Chapin Street
Binghamton, New York
Linda Jaffe
po box 4
meridale, ny
blanca McBrien
5 Wright Court
Lagrangeville, NY
Bernard Galiley
113 Lincoln Place
Brooklyn, NY
Nicole Bernheimer
390 Clinton Street, #3
Brooklyn, NEW YORK
James Marks
Cooper Street
Stone Ridge, NY
Eleanor Angier
5195 state rt. 38a
auburn, ny
Gary Oshust
31 1st Place #5
Brooklyn, NY
David Bruce
7795 Vermont Hill Rd
Holland, NY
Mary Baumgartner
36 Hudson Drive
New Windsor, New York
Sherrin Hersch
2000 broadway, 7D
new york, NY
Joshua Epstein
305 Stephenson Lane
New Windsor, NY
Lee Williams
396 Tompkins Avenue 4B
Brooklyn, New York
Barbara Kwasnik
203 Lewiston Drive
Syracuse, NY
Justine Baker
31-19 33rd Street
Astoria, NY
Karen Flood
472 State Route 55
Barryville, New York
Blake Winter
6313B W Quaker St
Orchard Park, NY
lisa Russell
P.O. Box 1019
Pearl River, New York
lenore silverstein
203 East 72nd Street
new york, ny
Sarah McConnell
81 Elmerston Road
Rochester, NY
Susan Harwood
387 Third Ave
Troy, New York
Elaine Cobb
P.B. 634
Little Falls, New York
mark Fisher
200 West 79th street
New York, NY
Julie Herzog
579 Engleville Road
Sharon Springs, NY
vincent valente
42 hickory street
port jefferson station, new york
Lillian Kaplan
94-20 Guy Brewer Blvd
Jamaica, New York
Patricia Seabrook
74 Meher Circle
Woodstock, NY
Rick Cook
736 West 187th Street, Apt 401
New York, NY
Adam Stein
111 Spring Valley Drive
Rochester, NY
David Herzog
579 Engleville Road
Sharon Springs, NY
Jeffrey Beach
497 Spencer Rd
Rochester, NY
Robert Roisman
248 Sugarwood Ln
Central Ialip, ny
John Bligh
9 Guilford School House Rd
New Paltz, New York
Alice Hill
312 East 90th Street
New York, NY
Susanne Slauenwhite
528 74th Street
Brooklyn, NY
CYNTHIA KELLY
68 Dutchess Terrace
Beacon, NY
Mary Waters
38 Pine Street
East Moriches, NY
Rebecca Chan
2118 Lerner Hall
New York, NY
Paige Ruane
302 W 12th Street, #183
New York, NY
Steve Dickman
1404 Livingston Place
Vestal, NY
joseph robert rosenthal, MD
249 E. 48 street
New York, NY
lynn silberman
340 east 63rd st. #1C
manhattan, NY
Rev.Marjorie Lipari
305 East 21St. Street
New York City, New York
thomas Cushwa
303 Park Ave. So. apt 511
New York, NY
Linda-Ann Marsch
444 Chelsea Drive
Islip, New York
Larry Zuckerberg
2172 Gerritsen Ave.
Brooklyn, New York
Dwain Wilder
289 Rich's Dugway
Rochester, NY
Cindy Horn
Berry Road
Lafayette, NY
Patrick Brennan
340 Crestwood Ave
Buffalo, New York
Shanelle Halling
137 Field St
Rochester, NY
Paul Dokuchitz
835 Riverside Drive
New York, NY
Barbara Klein
46 Amherst Street
Brooklyn, NY
Greg Drasler
137 Duane St.
New York, NY
Rachel Liebling
59 Russell St.
Brooklyn, NY
Thomas Butter
PO Box 117
Fremont Center, NY
Celeste Lilore
635 west42nd St
New york, Ny
BETTYE CALLISON-PALERMO
PO Box 115, 3626 Huntley Rd
Walworth, NY
Valentina Luccardi
18 Jones Ave
chatham, NY
Marlene Barken
125 Genung Circle
Ithaca, New York
Camille Habacker
4565 Route 55 East
Swan Lake, NY
CAROL SCOTT
414 East Beech St
Long Beach, New York
Gregory Rosenthal
908 Mohegan Road
Schenectady, New York
Naomi Weinstein
136 West 24th Street
New York, NY
Paul Wojciechowski, PhD
1007 East Lake Road
Dundee, NY
Bruce Young
PO BOx 153
Madison, NY
terri lukacko
106 hillcrest avenue
albany, ny
Jonathan Lang
20 Continental Avenue #2A
Forest Hills, NY
kate key
184 kent ave
brooklyn, ny
Joni Blackburn
113 Gulf Road
Roscoe, NY
Merritt Claude
4901 HH Pkwy (#7K)
Bx, NY
Frank M. Kirkland
80-20 138th Street, 2A
Briarwood, NY
Jason Fried
205 Conover St
Brooklyn, Ny
John Hynes
68 Centerport Road
Greenlawn, NY
robert negrin
25-59 41 street apt.4c
astoria, new york
Juliet Sunara
1437 First Avenue, apt 3FN
New York, NY
Isabelle Duvernois
225 west 70th street
new york, NY
Matthew Fried, Ph.D.
2 Hilltop Road
Margaretville, New York
Carolyn Broadaway
73 Oakwood Street
Albany, New York
Anthony Montanaro
78 Dolores Dr.
Rochester, Neww York
John Sentigar
206 Meserole St.
Brooklyn, NY
Arthur Friedman
6512 Ellwell Crescent
Rego Park, New York
Gezim Sherifi
23 Woodcrest DR
Nissequogue, NY
christopher scallon
350 E. 87th St.
New York, NY
L Skeddle
91 Payson Ave
New York, NY
Ellin Kristofik
31 Prestwick Court
Poughkeepsie, NY
P S Wolf
3388 Golda Cir
N Ft Myers, FL
Antonia Urbaez
2681 Heath Avenue
Bronx, New York
Kathleen O'Donnell
9 Hamilton Ave.
Croton on Hudson, NY
Frances Hannan
2743 Hyatt St
Yorktown Heights, NY
Ellen Darst
P.O. Box 39
Malden Bridge, NY
Henry Brooks
1247 Wildflower Drive
Webster, New York
Alan G
yorktown heights
yorktown heights, ny
Jose Diaz
15E Hunns Lake Rd
Stanfordville, NY
Christy SMith
652 Linden Street Apt. 2
Rochester, NY
Jessica Kroenert
7 Iroquois Avenue
Palisades, NY
Carol Lynne D'Arcangelis
10 Cross St.
Fort Plain, NY
Chris Saia
12 McGuinness Blvd. S.
Brooklyn,, New York
Tony Gill
10 Slocum Place
Brooklyn, NY
Sahaiya Abudu
524 Jefferson Ave
Brooklyn, NY
Calvin Armstrong
1922 Payton Circle
Colorado Springs, CO
Anne Kolesnikoff
64 Hungerford Rd
Ithaca, New York
Lynne Logan
232 Stafford Ave
Syracuse, NY
Joseph Powell
7 Rockridge Road
Larchmont, NY
Marta Tereshchenko
1560 West 10th Street, #3R
Brooklyn, , NY
Susan Singer
216 Millwood Road
Chappaqua, NY
David Fetzer
225 Parkwood Avenue
Rochester, NY
David Barken
125 Genung Cirlce
Ithaca, NY
Kevin Mulligan
9 Hamilton Ave.
Croton on Hudson, NY
ruth walker
661 Park Place #3
Brooklyn, NY
Richard Buckman
7Kenmore St
Dix Hills , NY
Gary Stahl
408 East 92nd Street
New York, NY
Tess Meyer
421 Columbia St
Brooklyn, NY
Thomas Catterson
7572 Foote Road
Clinton, New York
Devin Brown
600 Horsepound Rd.
Carmel, NY
Blake Simonsohn
8360 sw 154 st
Palmetto bay, Florida
Michael Lebron
36 Cooper Square Suite 7F
New York City, NY
sharon sonders
3205 emmons avenue
brooklyn, ny
Ed Jones
68 Stratford Rd. Apt. 7
Brooklyn, NY
Gina Bonilla
88-19 90th street
Woodhaven, NY
Jan Prokop
5 Bowers Lane
Great Neck, NY
Bonnie Anderson
38 Seventh Avenue
Brooklyn, New York
Donna Venn
4804 W. Main Rd.
Fredonia, NY
R Ryce-Paul
172 Attorney Street
NY, NY
Elisa Dorn
87 Montrose Ave
Brooklyn, NY
Robin Fox
20 Short Hill Road
Croton-on-Hudson, NY
Nicholas Silins
207 Willow Avenue
Ithaca, NY
Wm. David Plance
2179 Tupper Hill Rd.
Franklin, NY
Gerald Press
110 West 86th St
New York, NY
Bertram Singer
10 Chestnut Dr.
Pomona, ny
Margaret Day
366 Baltic St, Apt 2R
Brooklyn, NY
Elliott Greene
730 Meadowdale Road
Altamont, New York
MaryAnn Larson
20 Webster Street
Dunkirk, NY
G Kron
PO Box 697
Conklin, NY
Andrew Reinhardt
61 Tioronda Ave Apt 1
Beacon, NY
edward goldberg
307 prospect place
brooklyn, ny
Alexis Siroc
100 Fremont Street
Callicoon, NY
Jacob Halper
135 Eastern Parkway, #6E
Brooklyn, NY
peter stern
2333 effie street
los angeles, california
justine woolner wise
61 dietz
oneonta, ny
Alex Smith
3344 91 street
jackson heights, ny
Jason van Staveren
1250 Danby Rd
Ithaca, NY
Morris Rabinowitz
144 Garfield Place
Brooklyn, NY
Duncan Skiles
237 Union St
Brooklyn, NY
jonathan kane
pobox 544
jackson heights, ny
Xantha Karp
3524 Cambridge Ave
Bronx, NY
barbara zakrzewski
32 woods end road
hartsdale, new york
jason seidel
818 south street
chenango forks, new york
Deborah Franke Ogg
346 Beaverkill Road
Kingston, New York
Gerard Courtade
4820 Lincklaen Road
Cazenovia, NY
Joyce McKnight
20 Pine Rd.
Lake Luzerne, NY
John MacLean
6 Hamilton Avenue
Croton, NY
Rebekah Smith
77 Minnesota St
Rochester, ny
Julius Anderson
846 Bay Ridge Ave.
Brooklyn , New York
Ali Cetinkaya
246 east 53rd street
new york, NY
Ryan Carmichael
207 Montrose Ave
Brooklyn, New York
Jonathan Hirsch
46 Johnson Pl
Oceanside, New York
Deborah Allen
256 Hastings Avenue
Buffalo, Ny
Renee Toback
54 Fairfield Road
Yonkers, NY
Carol Jefferu
690 Tenth Street
Brooklyn, New York
Beth Mitchell
229 Ambergate Rd
DeWitt, New York
Julia Courtney
4968 County Route 14
Madrid, NY
Cara Brownell
1801 Dorchester Road #1-D
Brooklyn, NY
Richard Capozzi
618 Dean Street
Brooklyn, NY
Laurie Goodhart
5 Arden Craig Dr
Albany, NY
Stephen Viederman
135 East 83rd Street. 15A
New York, NY
linda and terence lover
449 fishcreek road
saugerties, New York
Alex Reeves
150 first ave
new york, NY
John Adamski
460 Geiger Road
Dansville, NY
Josh Gorfein
4 Honeysuckle Lane
Kings Park, NY
lee segui
285 ogden ave
teaneck , NJ
James Matlik
500 Ripplewood Drive
Rochester, NY
Kathleen Keske
622A President St.
Brooklyn, New York
SARAH NOVAK
3715 PANAMA STEDMAN RD.
MAYVILLE, NY
Linda Greenberg
420 East 86th St Apt. 6C
New York, NY
CARL GOODMAN
9 MAPLEWOOD LANE
NEW CITY, NY
Mark Broschinsky
570 W. 204th St. 2c
New York, NY
Maureen Cunningham
21 Hawthorne Ave
Delmar, NY
Kate Guidetti
1550 York ave
New York, New York
Jill Fenichell
169 Prospect Place
Brooklyn, NY
Peter Craig
6 Sugarwood Drive
Pittsford, NY
Maria Studer
127 Springtime Lane West
Levittown, NY
Steven Titus
77 Woolsey Street
Huntington,, NY
mike hannen
171 laburnam cresent
rochester, ny
Laura Nichols
1361 Rt. 414
Beaver Dams, NY
Scott Amundsen
556 Gifford Hill Road
Oneonta, NY
Jayson Tillapaugh
367 Goodrich Road
Edmeston, NY
Vanessa Favero
364 West 18th Street
New York, New York
Erika Petersen
514 West End Ave
New York, New York
dulce rosal
92-27 54 avenue
Elmhurst, New York
Dana Flavin
296 state route 32 north
New Paltz, New York
Estelle Bajou
465 West 152nd Street, #45
New York, NY
Laura Etter
5044 State Route 203
Nassau, New York
Robert Kirschner
2018 29th St
Astoria, NY
Nicholas Zizelis
201-17 42 Ave
Bayside, New York
Carol Stamets
203 Horton Lane
Port Ewen, NY
Mike Yuin
678 broadway apt 3
Brooklyn , ny
Daniel Hughes
5445 Sayles Corners Rd Moravia NY 13118
Moravia, NY
Becky Hammer-Lester
PO Box 191
Eaton, NY
Rosalie Valente
164 Fancher Road PO Box 349
Richmondville, NY
Theresa Harling
318 N. Titmus Dr.
Mastic, NY
Caroline Berninger
POBox 295
Stone Ridge, NY
Dr Frederic Koehler Sutter
10 Bay Street Landing 4AB
Staten Island, NY
donald ptak
11133 marble springs road
delevan, ny
Donnie Rotkin
366 11th Street
Brooklyn, NY
Scott Palmer
428 E 9th St #3
New York, NY
Bette Alexander
114 West 27th Street
New York, NY
Jeanne Gehret
46 Duncott Rd.
Fairport, NY
Vivian Walsh
Lake Rd
Pine Plains, NY
Roberta Preisler
75 Pierrepont street
Brooklyn, New York
Dana Anthony
1063 St. Paul St Apt #1
Rochester, NY
Roy Finamore
518 East 11 Street
New York, NY
Marilyn Whitesides
158 East 7th St. #E5
New York, NY
Debra Myers
2112 Michigan Rd.
Wayland, NY
Paul Bates
336 74th Street
Brooklyn, NY
Kira Hall
34-07 42nd Street
Long Island City, NY
Sarah Garrity
E 16th st
Brooklyn, NY
Michelle Markle
3221 Sawdust RD
Wayland, New York
William Hudson
300 Riverside Drive
New York, NY
Jeremy Walz
6 Mercer St
Albany, NY
Joslyn Pine
50 7th Avenue
Sea Cliff, NY
gretchen SCHULZ
26 0neta Road
Rochester, NY
Gina Ruberto
422 McDonald Ave., Apt.2F
Brooklyn, NY
Liz McGarrity
266 East Broadway, Apt. B801
New York, NY
Brad Walrod
5587 State Route 52
Kenoza Lake, NY
Jan Fisher
2761 Route 12B
Deansboro, NY
gwyneth phillips
124 cameron ave
merrick, ny
John Zimmermann
21Walnut Place
Oyster bay , NY
Brad Christen
228 8th Avenue, #15
New York, NY
Roberta Desalle
18 West 90th Street
New York, New York
Frank Jaskulski
100 Theresa Blvd
Binghamton, New York
caroline f. themm
300 riverside drive
new york, new york
Chris Lawrence
PO Box 71
High Falls, New York
Michael Merolla
PO Box 428 63 Harbor Beach Road
Miller Place, New York
Frank Kitchens
140 West Broadway, 5B
New York, NY
Danielle Loughran
33 Cedar St
Babylon, NY
Christopher Hightower
166 West 22nd Street
LONDON TERRACE, NY
Nicole Galan
1580 74th Street
Brooklyn, NY
Michael Murphy
435 Queens Hwy
Accord, NY
Robert Stack
315 8 Avenue Apt 6F
New York, NY
Mary Van Keuren
1057 Wayneport Road
Macedon, NY
Carol Olsen
423 Miles Ave.
staten island, NY
Daia Gerson
83 Smith Lane
Accord, NY
Cynthia Liss
901 80th Street
Brooklyn, NY
Frederik Rusch
600 W. End Av.
New York, New York
John Adams
2243 Beaverkill rd
Roscoe, New york
Marchand M. Finnegan
228 Darwin Drive
Amherst, New York
Nancy Haynes
275 Conover Street 5N
Brooklyn, NY
Bethany Fancher
3408 30th st
Astoria, NY
Matthew Potts
131 Vernon Ave Apt 3
Brooklyn, NY
Frank Carson
408 W. 34th St.
New York, NY
Emily Hursh
235 E 2nd St Apt A1
Brooklyn, NY
Stuart Blumner
370 1st Ave
New York, NY
Rachel Hankerson
Brooklyn, NY 11206
New York, NY
Martin Myers
761 Adirondack Road PO Box 280
Schroon Lake, New York
Teri Cameron
10224 Carousel Center
Syracuse, NY
Daniel Aliberte
629 w 170 st, 3G
New York, NY
Carol Blair
770 James St.
Syracuse, NY
Denise Szarek
7446 East South Street, Clinton, NY 13323
Clinton, New York
Patricia Marinaccio
43 Chapel Hill Drive
Brentwood, NY
Christopher Schilder
33 Gold St.
New York, NY
elaine peters
38 hollins road
hicksville, new york
Mela Lawson
6156 CR 27
Canton, NY
Mary Cosgrove
432 Western Avenue
Albany, New York
Yannai Kalman
65 Fraser St.
Staten Island, NY
Tom Garvey
15 Argyle Road
Merrick, NY
Pamela Creswell
14 Pine Street
Hankins, NY
Ken Fautz
43 Foxhall Ave.
Kingston, New York
Gerard T Dooney
45 Walton Avenue
Locust Valley, NY
William Wakefield
P. O. Box 393
DeRuyter, New York
Kristina Gsell
3574 Lerner Hall, 2920 Broadway
New York, NY
Frank Carson
48 N Manheim Blvd
New Paltz, NY
susan Zawoluk
43 River Avenue
Cornwall on Hudson, nY
Ellen Levin
203 West 22nd Street
New York, New York
Geeta Sangani
6896, Page hollow place
Fayetteville, NY
Wendy Liberatore
38 Salem Street
Greenwich, NY
Lis Harris
15 Claremont Ave. #32
N.Y., NY
Sara Schultz
65 Hunt Club Circle
East Amherst, NY
Kimi Nishikawa
28 County Route 70
Greenwich, New York
dennis rich
31 main st
w. seneca, ny
jaime cooper
76 rt. 71
Hillsdale, ny
Marc Epstein
27 John Street Apt 2
Kingston, NY
Doug Norton
Chicken Hollow Egg Ranch
Dansville, New York
Alex Tobias
2015 e. 7th St.
Brooklyn, NY
Jane Hughes Gignoux
201 West 89 Street
New York, New York
Ann Turner
8981 E Bluff Dr
Penn Yan, New York
Katherine Habib
10436 West Lake Rd
Hammondsport, NY
Miranda Gordon
28 east 10 th street apt 6e
New York, New York
Jan Goodwin
300 East 40th Street
New York, NY
james colello
jamescole249@yahoo.com
staten island, new york
Gary Ingraham
2117 Ford Road
Endicott, NY
Doris Tse
3001 Henry Hudson Pkwy
Riverdale, NY
Sean Harling
318 n titmus dr
mastic, new york
William Coleman
703 W Ferry St Apt C20
Buffalo, NY
GabrieleLibbey Libbey
240 Jefferson Ave
Harbor Isle, New York
Karin Ralph
9 Gwen Place
Greenlawn, NY
Stephen Klein
93 underhill #2D
Brooklyn, NY
Grey Morris
300 Houtman Road
Saugerties, NY
Jack Tyrie, Jr.
20 Baylis Street
Oswego, NY
matthew carter
207w 106st apt 9c
ny, ny
jason pyhtila
ithaca
ithaca, new york
Judith Schafer
--
New York , New York
Matthew Pawloski
415 gregory st 1st fl
Rochester, NY
Angelina Birney
P.O. Box 481
High Falls, New York
Daniel Lake
71 Macey Lane
Plattsburgh, New York (NY)
David Hogancamp
16 Summit Dr.
Pine City, NY
sandye renz
172 12th st.
brooklyn, Ny
Carolyn Brown
2827 Route 44
Millbrook, NY
Lynn Johnson
3213 State Route 9L
Lake George, NY
James Tate
281 West 11th Street apt 5A
New York, NY
Jake Jacobs
5 Richard Dr
W Nyack, NY
Lauren Cresswell
59 S Pine Ave
Albany, NY
Rebecca Darling
635 79th st
Brooklyn, Ny
Katherine Rabenau
62 FAIRVIEW AV
HANCOCK, New York
Jessica Flamholz
10 Ocean Pkwy
Brooklyn, NY
richard kinter
243 West 98th st.
nyc, ny
James Tate
281 West 11th Street apt 5A
New York, NY
Miriam Derivan
100 McKay Drive
Webster, NY
gaye georges
11 creek road
smithtown, new york
Amanda Kopet
850 Youkers Bush Rd.
Saint Johnsville, New York
Margaret Hughes
24 Crimi Circle
Highland, NY
Alan Prigal
25 Nelson road
Lake Huntington, NY
photini sinnis
3 Washington Sq. Village
New York, NY
Holly Noto
32 Jones Street; Apartment 1B
New York, NY
Andrew Abate
253 Kramer Dr.
Lindenhurst, NY
Christina Pennoyer
58 Villard Ave
Hastings-on-Hudson, NY
Herb Alter
875 West End Ave, Apt 8E
New York, NY
Jessica Cook
258 Buckingham Ave
Syracuse, NY
Mitchell Clark
460 N. Franklin Street, # 519
Syracuse, NY
brenda brooks
po box 295
unadilla, ny
John Abel
1001 Taughannock Blvd
Ithaca, NY
Anita Bayley
225 Unionville-Feura Bush
Feura Bush, NY
Danielle Raymond
3420 Tarbox Rd
Cassadaga, New York
Timothy LaVassar
3115 Burris Rd. #53
Vestal, New York
Thomas Rowan
766 Brady Avenue, Apt. 635
Bronx, NY
Raymond Swierczynski
10 Hillside Terrace
Suffern, NY
Miles Morris
49 Menahan St. #1R
Brooklyn, NY
Karen Kwasnowski
17 Highland Dr
Marcellus, NY
Patrick Shea
24-39 38th Street Apt. 8C
Astoria, NY
Vickie Stein
1317 County Road 32
Arkport, NY
Frances Button
9625 Scipio Rd
Dalton, NY
Thomas Smusz
49 Sidney Place #2
Brooklyn, NY
Edward Zimmermann PhD
44 Bloomfield Avenue
Depew, NY
Dan Sicchio
57 Mapleview Dr
Pennellville, NY
Claudia Leff
149 Highview St
Mamaroneck, NY
Madalyn Margoles
355 8th Avenue
New York, NY
Karl McCormack
19033 E Cottonwood Dr Apt 123
Parker, CO
David Yattaw
6822 Citation Way
Victor, NY
Jeffrey Kittay
152 Homestead Trail
White Lake, NY
shawn thomas
11 BILTOM RD
WHITE PLAINS, NY
Paul Fung
382 Central Park West, Apt. 14P
New York, New York
Donna Potak
Nichols Rd
Jefferson, NY
Joyce Abrams
30 Maple Ave.
Claverack, NY
Catherine Wolcott
616 E. 9th St. #4W
New York, NY
Michael DeLuzio
114 Highland Ave
Rochester, NY
Isabel Fisher
156 E 37th Street 9C
New York, NY
Cary Fassler
rd1
Amboy, NY
Jane Fordyce
16 Greene Street, 6S
New York, NY
RUSS DRAGO
67 bond street
westbury, ny
lois penn
206 east 9th street
new york, ny
angus gilchrist
46 power house rd
glen spey, NY
elisabeth Barbar
11 Deepwoods Lane
Old Greenwich, Ct
Nancy Mintz
35 Douglass Street
Brooklyn, NewYork
Gail Van Wie
24 Fenwick Rd
Hastings on Hudson, NY
Judi Ventress
341 W 24th St #2F
New York, New York
Bruce Berger
370 East 69th St.
NY, NY
shore david
20 meadowbrook dr
ossining, ny
Ruth Stone
1466 Hudson Ave
Stillwater, NY
Mark Solovey
55 Tompkins Ave
Hastings-On-Hudson, NY
Delia Fonseca
310 West 143rd Street #1c
New York, NY
Avi Glickstein
221 East 18th Street
Brooklyn, NY
Ben Katchor
240 West 102 St., #34
New York, NY
Layne Negrin
457 Classon Ave #8
Brooklyn, NY
Jonathan Nash
500 East 83rd Street, #10B
New York, NY
Terry Weld
9827 Ossian Hill Road
Dansville, NY
Meredith Chilson
County Road 2B
Belmont, NY
Irene Schacher
226 Homestead Village Drive
Warwick, New York
Gregory Smith
112 Lincoln Ave, 214
Bronx, NY
K. David Cook
121 Norfolk St #3
New York, NY
Andrew Melzer
112-01 Queens Blvd
Forest Hills, NY
Steven Dreier
PO Box 701150
East Elmhurst, NY
Norman Sukkar
80 E. 2nd St.
NY, NY
Nobu Fukui
141 West 26th Street,
New York, NY
Pablo Vasile
725 4th Ave
Brooklyn, NY
Jennifer Benusis
27 warren todd subdivision rd
arkville, ny
karen Marrero
n/a
new york, ny
Janet Easton
P.O. Box 56
Woodstock, NY
James Ring
4278 Sheva Lane
Hamburg, New York
Rebecca Steere
147 Sweetfield Circle
Yonkers, NY
lisa luborsky
1496 Wittenberg Road
Mount Tremper, NY
Marina Morrone
46-42 Vernon Boulevard
Long Island City, NY
Matthew Sukkar
80 E. 2nd St.
NY, NY
Olivia Wong
552 Riverside Dr
New York, NY
Greg Tyler
1 Evergreen Lane
Cazenovia, NY
e hills
rt 203
chatham, ny
diana Butsch
8030 burr
west falls , ny
Daniel McCormack
13 Beehive Road
Accord, New York
sara clark
173 prospect pl
bklyn, ny
Paul Sperduto
13709 County Hwy 23
Unadilla, NY
gina speirs
500 east 11 street , apt 25
new york, NY
Jackson Sukkar
80 E. 2nd St.
NY, NY
Jen Nam
112 Lincoln Ave, 214
Bronx, NY
Simon Jaworski
Box 301
Centerport, New York
Grayce Paul-Dierkes
720 Church Rd
Hudson, NY

Pages