You are here

Coalition Letter to Governor Cuomo to Withdraw RD SGEIS

November 2, 2011

Honorable Andrew M. Cuomo
Governor of New York
The State Capital
Albany, NY 12224

Dear Governor Cuomo:

We, the undersigned, strongly support safeguarding the environment, public health, natural resources and scenic splendor of New York’s Catskills, Finger Lakes and Southern Tier regions. With that goal in mind, we request that you immediately withdraw the Marcellus Shale revised draft Supplemental Generic Environmental Impact Statement (RD SGEIS) in order to resolve the fundamental shortcomings documented herein.

There is a de facto moratorium on horizontal hydrofracturing in New York’s Marcellus Shale pending adoption of a Final SGEIS. The Department of Environmental Conservation’s (DEC) 2009 Draft SGEIS received such withering criticism that Governor Paterson signed Executive Order No. 41 requiring DEC to: “make such revisions to the Draft SGEIS that are necessary to analyze comprehensively the environmental impacts associated with high-volume hydraulic fracturing combined with horizontal drilling, ensure that such impacts are appropriately avoided or mitigated …” On 1/1/11, you signed a “continuation” of that Order.

The RD SGEIS Must Be Withdrawn Due to DEC’s Failure to Fulfill Executive Order No. 41

DEC’s RD SGEIS fails to fulfill the mandate of Executive Order No. 41. First and foremost, it is based on the erroneous assertion that:

“No documented instances of groundwater contamination are recorded in the Department’s files from previous horizontal drilling or hydraulic fracturing projects in New York. No documented incidents of groundwater contamination in public water supply systems were reported by the NYSDOH central office and Rochester district office... References have been made to some reports of private well contamination in Chautauqua County in the 1980s that may be attributed to oil and gas drilling... The reported Chautauqua County incidents, the majority of which occurred in the 1980s and which pre-date the current casing and cementing practices and fresh water aquifer supplementary permit conditions, could not be substantiated because pre-drilling water quality testing was not conducted, improper tests were run which yielded inconclusive results and/or the incidents of alleged well contamination were not officially confirmed.”

This statement is factually incorrect and deliberately misleading. Hundreds of natural gas and oil drilling, hydrofracturing and related problems have reportedly impacted private water wells, homes and the environment in New York. Those problems are documented by DEC as well as health authorities in Chautauqua, Cattaraugus and Allegany counties.

Ferrugia’s “Well Documented” Drinking Water Problem “Seemingly Related to Gas Well Development”

For example, DEC is well aware that the Ferrugia family near Jamestown, NY has not been able to drink their well water since 2007 after a gas well was drilled approximately 300 feet from their home. Their water is so polluted that their veterinarian even warned them not to allow their dogs to drink the water. Chautauqua County Health authorities determined: “This is a well documented case showing drinking water impacts that are seemingly related to gas well development.” Yet, DEC has refused to assist this family.

The Ferrugia’s problem directly refutes the RD SGEIS assertions about gas drilling incidents in Chautauqua County because it: a) occurred relatively recently and is on-going; b) was not prevented by DEC regulatory safeguards or gas well drilling and production improvements; c) is documented by pre-drilling and post-drilling drinking water baseline testing and d) was confirmed by local health officials.

See an interview with Mr. David Ferrugia and extensive documents regarding his water well problem at: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0Ka0QJaKZ4s and http://www.toxicstargeting.com/node/7084

Dave Eddy’s Confirmed Drinking Water Contamination in Andover, NY

The Ferrugias are not the only New Yorkers who reportedly were impacted by inadequate regulation of gas drilling. Mr. Dave Eddy and his family experienced drinking water contamination and gas intrusion into their home, reportedly due to hydrofracturing of nearby gas wells. His water pollution was confirmed by the gas drilling firm. See: http://www.toxicstargeting.com/MarcellusShale/videos/andover_independenc... and http://www.toxicstargeting.com/MarcellusShale/documents/allegany_us_ener...

Recently Reported Natural Gas and Oil Spills Further Document DEC’s Regulatory Shortcomings

DEC's hazardous materials spills database identifies hundreds of on-going failures to clean up oil and gas drilling pollution impacts, including at least 72 recently reported natural gas and oil concerns. See: http://www.toxicstargeting.com/sites/default/files/pdfs/jamestown/group1... These problems further document DEC’s regulatory enforcement shortcomings. For example:

LITTLE WELL - EAST SULLIVANVILLE ROAD HORSEHEADS, NY, 6/23/2011: EQUIPMENT FAILURE – BRINE – 200 gallons. “APPROX 200 GALLONS OF BRINE WATER TO GRAVEL AT WELL SITE. THE SPILL WAS THE RESULT OF A LEAK IN A PORTABLE STORAGE TANK.” Meets Cleanup Standards: NO.

STOSCHEK WELL - 49 BECKHORN HOLLOW ROAD VAN ETTEN, NY, 3/8/2010: EQUIPMENT FAILURE – BRINE – 756 gallons. “VALVE ON THE BRINE TANK FROZE AND BROKE. ALLOWING ABOUT 18 BARRELS OF BRINE TO LEAK OUT.” Meets Cleanup Standards: NO.

POYSA WELL #E1 - 61 BRIGGS HILL ROAD VAN ETTEN, NY, 4/8/2011: EQUIPMENT FAILURE – BRINE – 693 gallons. “Valve on brine tank at closed-in well froze and cracked allowing a release of 16.5 barrels of fairly fresh brine.” Meets Cleanup Standards: NO.

GRUNERT NO. 1 WELL – SOUTH MAIN STREET EXTENSION [?], NY NO ZIP PROVIDED, 6/1/2011: EQUIPMENT FAILURE – CRUDE OIL – 200 gallons. “LEAKING ABOVEGROUND PLASTIC TANK THAT’S INVOLVED WITH GAS WELL.” Meets Cleanup Standards: NO.

TUSCARORA BRINE APPLICATION – TOWN OF TUSCARORA DIRT ROADS TUSCARORA, NY, 6/21/2010: DELIBERATE – BRINE. “Caller states Town is using brine from gas wells to control dust on dirt roads and are applying it way too heavy causing runoff to ditches and streams. Also concerned about his well and what might be in the brine.” Meets Cleanup Standards: NO.

A total of more than 400 historic natural gas and oil concerns are documented by DEC and local health authorities. These concerns refute DEC’s assertion that gas extraction problems do not exist: http://www.toxicstargeting.com/sites/default/files/pdfs/jamestown/CCDOH-... and http://www.toxicstargeting.com/MarcellusShale/drilling_spills_profiles

At Least 16 Additional Reasons Why the RD SGEIS Must be Immediately Withdrawn

In addition to the regulatory enforcement problems noted above, the RD SGEIS must be immediately withdrawn and sent back to the drawing board because it does not resolve key concerns voiced by Region 2 of the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), academic researchers, citizens and local officials. It fails to:

1. Afford equal health protection to all New Yorkers living above the Marcellus Shale formation. The RD SGEIS proposes to ban Marcellus Shale horizontal hydrofracturing in the New York City and Syracuse watersheds and above State Lands and primary aquifers (at least temporarily). If horizontal hydrofracturing is not allowed in those areas, it cannot be considered “safe” for other areas of New York.

2. Resolve mortgage lending problems associated with gas leasing. The RD SGEIS ignores gas leasing impacts on mortgage lending documented by lenders, including lender reluctance to secure mortgage loans with properties with gas leases; concerns about property valuation and marketability; "set-back" issues regarding the sale of mortgage loans on the "secondary" market and potential voiding of title insurance. See: http://www.toxicstargeting.com/MarcellusShale/alerts/natural-gas-leasing...

3. Assess horizontal hydrofracturing conducted at the same well pad in both Marcellus Shale and underlying Utica Shale. The RD SGEIS does not address this potential practice, but EPA views it as a matter of grave concern. See: http://toxicstargeting.com/sites/default/files/pdfs/map-email-responses-...

4. Ban gas drilling wastewaters from being discharged into Publicly Owned Treatment Works designed for sanitary waste or adopt strict pretreatment standards. POTWs are not designed, constructed or maintained to remove or break down the high levels of Total Dissolved Solids (TDS), toxic petroleum constituents and radionuclides documented in gas drilling wastewater. EPA reports that shale gas extraction wastewater contaminants may "'pass through' the POTW, causing the POTW to violate its permit, cause 'interference' with the POTW's operation, or contamination of biosolids..." Pennysylvania has banned this practice. EPA has just begun the process of adopting national pretreatment standards for gas drilling wastewaters. See: http://www.toxicstargeting.com/MarcellusShale/documents/letters/2011/06/...

5. Ban toxic gas drilling wastewater from being recycled as hydrofracturing or drilling fluid. Gas drilling wastewaters, including "flowback" as well as "brine" or "produced water," are currently exempted from “GA” effluent limitations designed to safeguard drinking water drawn from the ground in New York. The RD SGEIS fails to eliminate this exemption even though gas drilling wastewater is documented to contain up to 413,000 parts per million of TDS, 72,600 parts per billion of Total Petroleum Hydrocarbons in the diesel range as well as benzene up to 660 parts per billion. Those pollutant concentrations would vastly exceed applicable GA effluent limitations. For example, benzene is only allowed at one part per billion in permitted groundwater discharges.

6. Ban land-spreading of toxic gas drilling wastewaters. DEC allows gas drilling brine to be spread on land for dust control, roadbed stabilization and melting ice and snow. EPA recommended: "A program must be implemented to properly manage the elevated radionuclide concentrations in the brine to protect the worker health, public health, and the environment." The practice of gas drilling wastewater spreading must be halted.

7. Resolve inadequate DEC staffing problems. The infamous memo that caused DEC Commissioner Grannis to be fired noted: "Many of our programs are hanging by a thread. The public would be shocked to learn how thin we are in many areas;" The memo further noted: "While the risks to human health have already increased due to cuts to certain environmental quality programs, and especially to enforcement activities related to pollution sources, further cuts would result in unacceptable risks to New Yorkers and unacceptable liability for New York State government (emphasis added)." Governor Cuomo cut DEC’s budget in 2011. See: http://www.toxicstargeting.com/sites/default/files/dec_dobletter_Grannis...

8. Identify New York areas prone to higher seismic activity and propose measures to prevent earthquakes potentially associated with horizontal hydrofracturing. EPA reported that: "The dSGEIS notes that the State of New York is fairly active seismically. EPA recommends that NYSDEC limit the number of wells in areas of higher seismic activity, or require additional protective measures and monitoring." See: http://www.toxicstargeting.com/MarcellusShale/documents/comments/2009/31...

9. Adopt comprehensive radionuclide standards to safeguard gas drilling workers, public health and the environment. EPA notes that "radionuclide concentrations specified in the DSGEIS represent elevated radionuclide concentrations and need to be handled, managed, and disposed of appropriately to avoid unnecessary exposure to workers, the public, and the environment." EPA also determined that "such concentrations are considered elevated and may pose unacceptable human health risk mainly via external exposure, inhalation of radon and thoron decay products, and to some degree via inadvertent ingestion."

10. Resolve EPA concerns about inadequate protection of Ecosystems and Wildlife. EPA reported: "This section [7.4] is incomplete, and does not account for the changes in the ecosystems in New York State since the preparation of the 1992 GEIS. For example, more animals and plants are on federal and state endangered species lists, habitats of all kinds are more fragmented, invasive species have impacted existing animal and plant populations, and climate change has impacted plant and animal ranges and migrations.”

11. Assess "cumulative impacts" on a comprehensive basis. EPA notes that it is "concerned that cumulative and indirect impacts need to be more thoroughly discussed in the dSGEIS. Even with its generic format, the EIS should discuss the impacts that may result from past, present, and reasonably foreseeable future projects as well as those impacts associated with drilling and hydrofracturing that may occur later in time and/or further from the immediate project site."

12. Update the 1992 GEIS. EPA notes that it is "concerned that over the past 17 years since the 1992 GElS was written, the 'existing' environment and conditions in New York State have changed sufficiently that using the information from that report as a baseline for the dSGEIS will not take into account the cumulative impacts from habitat fragmentation, population increase, and climate change that may have occurred during that time."

13. Require compliance with a critical EPA policy change regarding air quality assessment. Shortly after the draft SGEIS was released on 9/30/09, EPA adopted a major new policy regarding New Source Review (NSR) and Title V permitting programs pursuant to the Clean Air Act. This reversed the EPA policy in effect when the draft SGEIS was prepared. The new policy changes the requirements for "source aggregation" for air permitting programs. According to a DEC Powerpoint slide: "Since level of aggregation must be case by case, SGEIS cannot provide definitive answers (emphasis added)." See: http://www.nytimes.com/gwire/2009/10/14/14greenwire-epa-tosses-bush-era-... and http://toxicstargeting.com/sites/default/files/pdfs/powerpoint_foil-4pg.pdf

14. Eliminate DEC’s current hazardous waste regulatory exemption for gas drilling wastes and impose strict liability for cleaning up gas drilling pollution hazards.

15. Require the New York State Department of Health to share co-lead agency status with DEC and assess health impacts on a comprehensive basis.

16. Require immediate disclosure of uncontrolled gas drilling pollution releases, establish a dedicated fund to remediate gas drilling hazards and require gas drilling firms to provide financial surety for remediating problems by posting bonds or providing insurance coverage.

Conclusion

The RD SGEIS fails to provide a meaningful plan to safeguard New York from the irreparable harm that could be caused by the vast industrialization associated with Marcellus Shale horizontal hydrofracturing. Unless and until DEC resolves its regulatory enforcement problems and addresses the additional concerns documented herein, New York’s de facto moratorium on horizontal hydrofracturing in Marcellus Shale must not be lifted.

We trust that you will find our request self-explanatory. Thank you for your consideration. We look forward to your prompt reply.

Very truly yours,

Total Signatory Count: 22949

Glenn Curtis
8200 French Hill Rd
Naples, NY
Louis Linder
21 Pine Rd
Briarcliff Manor, NY
Melissa Philip
301 Enfield center rd. west
Ithaca, NY
Richard Kleeman
125 Castle Heights Avenue
Upper Nyack, New York
Mitchell Blanco
251 E Kingsbridge Rd
Bronx , NY
Marianne Wodnick
4280 Stonebridge Road
Morrisville, NY
Matthew Minarchek
15 Penny Lane
Ithaca, NY
Miles Colaprete
635 Sterling pl
Brooklyn, Ny
Paul Gallery
2882 River Road
Niskayuna, New York
Patricia Byrne
133 Gabel Rd.
Callicoon, NY
Staci Strobl
305 W. 111th St. #1A
New York, NY
Frank voso
52 Knoll Road
Southampton, NY
Curt Leyser
806 Bergern St. #4
Brooklyn, NY
Dwight Peiffer
4 Fowlerhouse Road
Wappingers Falls, New York
Diana Barros
1790 Madison Avenue
New York, New York
Tracey Olmoz
4 dr. fink road
pleasant valley, ny
Patricia Foster
89 Meyer Road
Middletown, New York
Roxane Offner
21 Fairview Ave. #624
Tuckahoe, NY
thomas cingel
379 Broadway
kingston, ny
Ivette Lenard
42 Demarest Av
W. Nyack, NY
Laura Loveland - Leitch
16 Glencairn Ct
Liverpool, NY
Michael Herbold
85 Rhode Island Street
Buffalo, NY
Paul Zimmerman
324 Bergen St.
Brooklyn, NY
Stu Hackel
38 Maplewood Ave.
Dobbs Ferry, NY
David Johnson
535 Dean Street, Ph109
Bklyn, NY
Sally Allison
289 Lake Meadow Dr.
Rochester, NY
JOHN DEMASTRI
332 Bleecker ST
New York, New York
celia holtzberg
201 East 21st 16D
New York, NY
Laurie Davis
286 Miner St Rd
Canton, New York
David Bradley
93 Flower Street,
Buffalo, NY
Donna Lynne Champlin
400 west 43rd street #40B, NYC, NY. 10036
NYC, NY
Mayelly Moreno
5-7 Minetta Street, Apt. 1F
New York, NY
anthony Rago
1614 Cr 26
Climax, NY
Nicholas Assenza
348 West 23rd Street
Deer Park, NY
Lucia Rahilly
165 Prospect Park West, #3R
Brooklyn, NY
Denise Gibson
3135 Godwin Ter
Bronx, NY
Jonathan Neufeld
491 Park Place
Brooklyn, NY
Doug Ballard
151 Dutch st
Montrose, Ny
Patrina Huff
18 Irving Ave., 1C
Brooklyn, New York
Anna Clifford
3269 N Summit Ave
Watkins Glen, NY
Surley Castro de Moreno
2779 Atlantic Avenue, Apt. 2
Brooklyn, NY
ilyana kadushin
East 3rd st.
brooklyn, New York
Robert Orzel
PO Box 227
Mill Neck, NY
Pini Churgin
3543 Knight St
Oceanside, NY
Penelope Pi-Sunyer
443 East Mt. Road South
Cold Spring, NY
Brian McGonigle
71 71st Street
Brooklyn, NY
Richard Jones
215 W. 91 Street
New York, NY
Matthew Sterling
6 Marion Street
Mohawk, New York
George Saunders
4513 State Highway 28 South
Oneonta, NY
James Henrickson
415 Third Ave Ext
Frankfort, NY
Rocky Pinciotti
76 Cross Rd
Cochecton, NY
Celia Ballou
223 Devoe Street
Brooklyn, NY
Jonathan Lynch
34 Besemer Hill Rd
Ithaca, NY
Jeff Gilhart
151 Shore Drive
Rochester, NY
William Van Wie
24 Fenwick Road
Hastings-on-Hudson, New York
Sonya Friedman
38 W. 10 St.
N Y, N Y
Arthur Salo
11 Foxpointe Circle
Fairport, New York
William Judson
145 East 57th Street
New York, NY
Elaine Epstein
370 heritage hills -unit A
Somers, Ny
Erin Ergenbright
5316 NE 10th Ave
Portland, OR
Joseph Stashkevetch
77 Payson Avenue #2
NYC, NY
Christopher Beall
110 Saint George Ct
Hurley, New York
Phyllis Wrynn
559 Tenth Street
Brooklyn, NY
Nancy Alessi
4228 County Route 24
Russell, NY
Theresa Janetatos
44 Prospect Park West
Brooklyn, NY
Joseph Oliansky
1815 Palmer Ave., apt. 1R
Larchmont, N.Y.
Karen Krieger
4 Ryan Road
North Branch, NY
Joachim Frank
200 West End Ave. #11A
New York, NY
Robert Belina
235 Pleasant Ridge Road
Poughquag, NY
Blair Tuckman
100 Beekman Street, Apt. 23N
New York, NY
William C Buell
4818 West Lake Road
Geneva, NY
Joel Spiegelman
165 East 19th Street 5g
Brooklyn, New York
Carol Lawyer
2844 Henneberry Road
Pompey, New York
Hahn Rowe
742 E 6TH ST
NEW YORK, NY - New York
claude niquet
118 spring street
new york, New York
james Rice
964a heritage hills
somers, ny
Andrew Gurman
235 E. 73rd St. Apt. 2B
New York, NY
Katherine Peabody
14 Renee's Way
East Hampton, NY
Sonja Stark
56 Silver Creek Drive
Selkirk, NY
Lynne Teplin
830 Palmer Road #3B
Bronxville, NY
Lori Wilson
PO Box 328
New Berlin, NY
John Fudjack
145 Pawling Ave
Troy, NY
Michael Coughlan
136 java Street
brooklyn, NY
John DeLawder
60 Overhill Road
Stormville, NY
Bruce Rosen
600 West End Avenue apt. 1A1
New York, NY
Mimi Jolidon
1 Capron St 3E
Rochester, NY
Heidi Jensen
22 West Meadow Road
Setauket, New York
Jesus Tamez
228 East 26th Street
New York, NY
Frank Boros
54 west 74 th street # 310
New York, NY
Peter Kinoy
404 E 18 St.
Brooklyn, NY
Robert Pruzek
409 Brownville Rd
Gansevoort, NY
Cyan Corwine
2084 Rt 417
Andover, NY
Kimberly Hines
135 High St
Avon, NY
william van wie
24 Fenwick Road
Hastings-on=Hudson, New York
john jay gebhardt
17 e 97th apt 5d
new york, new york
Lillian Forman
259 Bleecker St, Apt 30
New York, NY
Jackie Goodrich
253 Prospect Place
Brooklyn, NY
Eric Ott
4724 E Bates Rd.
Trumansburg, NY
Daniel Berndt
300 W 23rd St
New York, NY
Anthony Cavone
1679 County Rte 57 S
Fulton, New York
Carolyn Legg
3920 State Street
Skaneateles, NY
Anthony Bennett
286 E 2nd St 4B
New York, NY
Carl Linich
127 Van Wagner Rd.
Poughkeepsie, NY
David Ogeen
256 East Avenue
Batavia, NY
Ronnie Ann Himmel
124 Atlantic Ave A3C
Brooklyn, NY
Andrea Annechino
1657 Hilton Parma Road
Spencerport, NY
Bonnie Avery
812 Alden Rd.
Louisville, KY
John Langton
43 Elm Lane
Ancramdale, NY
Annie Marter
143 Thames St
Brooklyn, NY
Tom DeSimone
684 State Route 208
Gardiner, NY
Lois Richman
310 Roosevelt Blvd.
Long Beach, NY
barbara weiler
57 travis road, garrison , ny
garrison, ny
Richard Cullen
164 South Shore Rd.
Edinburg, NY
Marylou Wagner
168 St Hwy 80
Fort Plain, NY
Pedro Perez-Ortiz
724 Amsterdam Avenue Apt. 4-B
New York, New York
Susan McCormack
1145 West Beech Street
East Atlantic Beach, NY
Donna Simonie
116 Jones Rd
Sharon Springs, NY
Susan Knieser
53 Lakeside Rd
Newburgh, New York
caitlyn davey
406 chambers hollow rd
delhi, ny
Denise Shavers
105 Duane Street, #16c
New York, NY
Lori Feeley
56 Valley Lane
Chappaqua, NY
Mark Raczkowski
3660 2nd St.
Blasdell, New York
JILL TARAN
2479 WILLIAMS COURT
BELLMORE, NY
Wendy Pierson
170 Claremont Avenue #23
New York City, NY
Mitch Freidlin
559 Tenth St.
Brooklyn, New York
Glenn Mitchell
600 W 218th St.
New York, NY
Michael Larson
St. John's Pl.
Brooklyn, NY
Christine Edwards
108 Nassau Ave
Brooklyn, NY
Robert Jacobson
342 Dean St.
Brooklyn, NY
Lacey Sischo
2451 1st Avenue
East Meadow, NY
Tiayana Marks
330 Greene Ave #4
Brooklyn, NY
Machi Tantillo
65 Carmine St #d2
NY, NY
jill nord
7715 62 st
glendale, ny
Jay Fortunato
35 East 9th Street #32
New York, NY
Dexter Jeannotte
74 Bostock Road
Shokan, NY
Sarah Sportman
3 ninth ave
Watervliet, NY
Nina Cucchiari
69 Horton Rd
Cold Spring, NY
Karen Macbride
58 Sky View Drive
Callicoon, NY
Karen D'Andrea
21 Willowdale Rd
Scarborough, ME
Grace Remorca
412 West 25th Street
NY, NY
Ernest Chanes
216 East 18th Street
New York, New York
Kit Jones
138 Old Danzer Road
Livingston Manor, NY
Nan Pardee
67 W Elizabeth St
Skaneateles, Ny
Caroline LANE
150 25 72ND RD, APT 3C
KEW GARDENS HILLS, NY
Norma Watson
6 Bobs Lane
Setauket, NY
Carol Krinsky
100 Washington Square East, #303
New York, NY
Vaughn Watson
2 Indian Trace
Kings Park , NY
Deborah Coconis
5398 Route 82
Clinton Corners, NY
joann eckstut
154 Bryan Rd.
Rensselaerville, NY
Stephen Sacks
138 Remsen St
Brooklyn, NY
Rosalyn Baxandall
2 WSV #11B
NYC, NY
Renee Greer
3930 Laurel Canyon blvd
Studio City, NY
Scott Weiss
Box 442
Sag Harbor, N.Y.
Julian Parks
65-61 Saunders St., Apt. 2-H
Rego Park, New York
Anna Saether
8 Rhododendron Drive
Center Moriches, Ny
Chris Fiorentini
343 4th Ave
Brooklyn, NY
Susan Rapalee
135 Ocean Parkway
Brooklyn, NY
Harper Kitching
49-16 Weeks Lane
Fresh Meadows, N.Y.
Susan Schepp
180 Marion st
Rochester, NY
Armando Fente
398 Henry Street
Brooklyn, NY
cathy cioffi
514 Ohayo Mtn Rd
woodstock, NY
Susanna Yurick
567 9th street
Brooklyn, NY
Betsy Feist
140 East 81 Street Apt. 8G
New York, NY
Nancy DeTine
4 Soldiers Place
Buffalo, NY
Ayala Kalman
4400 Vestal Parkway E
Binghamton, NY
Laurie Fendrich
915 Callicoon Center Road
Callicoon Center, NY
Jeannette Rice
31 Pond Hill Road
Rensselaerville, New York
Ruth Lanton
15 Mitchell Ave
Plainview, NY
Sebastian Guzmam
12-14 27th Ave. Apt. 3
Astoria, New York
Paul Blitzblau
234 West Hickory Street
Canastota, NY
Julia Simons
108 Rose lawn
Highland, NY
Robert Breckenridge
159 West 85th #2A
New York, NY
Melissa Brown
189 E 3rd ST
New York, NY
Sarah Hesson
636 Sterling Pl
Brooklyn, NY
John Van Slyke
3363 East Lake Rd
Skaneateles, NY
c chittenden
6 stoneleigh trail
victor, ny
Jennifer Makepeace-Yerkovich
8945 State rt 53
Naples , New York
Erin Hogeboom
296 Saint Marks Ave.
Brooklyn, NY
Elizabeth Hoak
189 Rush Mendon Townline Rd
Honeoye Falls, NY
Gretchen Baudenbacher
109 Ryerson St
Brooklyn, New York
Frank Carfora
62 Park Circle South
Farmingdale, NY
Terril Bentley
2834 Pee Dee Road
Bliss, NY
daniel gobeo
20 roberts st
Middletown, New York
Virginia Brooks
170 West End Ave
New York, NY
Bruce Barry
20 Black Locust Ave
East Setauket, NY
Anthony Velez
5440 Netherland Avenue #D13
Bronx, NY
david kiremidjian
box 1555
southold, ny
Eunjung Han
4400 Vestal Parkway E
Binghamton, NY
Mike Doolin
220 Highland Pkwy
Rochesterq, NY
Glenn Hinchey
117 Gertrude St
Syracuse, NY
josephit franco
796 park ave.
uniondale, NY
Katja Lindskog
523 W112 Street, Apt 21B
New York, NY
Elisabeth Vines
9 Glendale Avenue
Delmar, NY
Richard Dallara
1551 Williamsbridge Rd
Bronx, New York
Ron Kerner, Ph.D.
12 Cemetery Lane
Setauket, NY
Paul Schneider
2656 York Road West
York, New York
Harold Niver
4 merryhill rd
wynantskill, NY
beth caspar
442 van brunt st.
brooklyn, NY
Charles Straut
1021 E. 87th St., #6A
Brooklyn, NY
Diane Malone
141 Young St.
Port Orange, Florida
Jessica Tomb
376 West Street
New York, NY
Deirdre McKiernan Hetzler
16 Silver Fox Dr,
Fairport, NY
Mikki Chalker
119 Prospect St
Binghamton, NY
Arlene and Albert Grand
933 Lawrence Court
North Bellmore, NY
B. S.
995 Broadway
Brooklyn, NY
Zoya Kocur
50 Park Terrace East
New York, New York
Margaret Guzzetta
20 Cattaraugus St.
Staten Island, NY
John Cisne
27 N. Landon Road
Ithaca, NY
Eric Yun
2355 Claire Court
Yorktown Heights, NY
Allison Jackle
4400 Vestal Parkway E
Binghamton, NY
Andrew Nolan
725 e 9th st
New York, Ny
Alan Hollander
1473 hewlett ave
hewlett, nY
Andrea Poropatich
158 Saint James Place
Brooklyn, NY
Amy Weidner
79-10 34th Avenue
Jackson Heights, NY
Roger Hoffman
Box 231
Hamilton, NY
Emi Katayama
2846 34th St. #1b
Astoria, NY
Paul Packer
49 Bell Circle
Port Jefferson , NY
William Breuer
5 Gold Circle
Malverne, NY
Yehia Yehya
530 bay ridge pkwy
brooklyn, new york
Ann Drobnik
30 Ocean Parkway
Brooklyn, NY
Jason Brill
46 Fawn Street
Saranac Lake, NY
Paul Puccio
63 St. Clair Dr.
Delmar, Ny
Stacia Van Slyke
3363 east lake road
Skaneateles, Ny
Erin Marshall
45 Greenway N
Albany, NY
John Clark
64 East Mohawk St
Oswego, NY
Daniel Hibbitts
181 Honeywell Corners Road
Broadalbin, New York
Anthony Parris
484 Cogea Ave.
Brooklyn, NY
Amanda Assini
517-309 University Avenue
Rochester, NY
vincent mcdonough
193preston ave.
staten island, n.y.
Casey Kurtti
18 Spongia Road
Stone Ridge, New York
Hallie Stotler
250 W 99th St.
New York, NY
Debra Williams
303 E 8th Street
New York, NY
R Crimmins
franklin ave
Brooklyn, NY
RoAnne Gatt
311 West Beech St
Long Beach, NY
Alan Barbier
509 RT 214
Chichester, New York
Larry Warshauer
72 Southside Drive
Monroe, NY
Alyson Montgomery
4400 Vestal Parkway E
Bin, NY
Michael Spano
181 Genesee Ave.
Staten Island, NY
Jonathan Moll
29 Charles Street, #4F
New York, NY
Lee Wiggins
209 E. 56th St.
New York, NY
Angela Mogavero
wellington
schenectady, ny
Mauricio Medina
266 Blackman Hill Road
Berkshire, New York
Jayne Port
246 Smith Rd
Newfield, NY
Bill Prestia
316 w pine st
long beach, ny
Krista Dunn
15 french
utica, ny
mark futral
390 warburton ave
hastings on hudson, new york
Brian Rausse
190 East Mosholu Parkway South
Bronx, NY
arden scott
404 atlantic ave
greenport, ny
Elizabeth Kidder
444 5th St. #3
Brooklyn, NY
Libby Brennan
33 burwell avenue
lancaster, NY
Roseanne Courtade
4820 Lincklaen Road
Cazenovia, NY
Joan Allen
438 East Avenue
Watertown, NY
Stuart Frankel
141 E 3rd St, Apt 8B
New York, NY
Wiliam Miller
536 East 82nd Street, #1C
New York, NY
m mogavero
wellington
rotterdam, ny
Marisa Levy
4400 Vestal Parkway E
Binghamton, NY
David Feld
2076 29th street apt 1
Astoria, Ny
Kiera DeCanio
P.O. Box 306
Wells, NY
anne mehlinger
36 frankel rd.
Massapequa, ny
Stephen Kutikoff
53 Marshall Drive
Carmel, New York
Rebecca Stanton
106 W 116th St
New York, NY
Sylvia Fogel
211 Central Park West #8K
New York, NY
kenneth brockett
6384 fisher hill
CANANDAIGUA, NY
George Zalantis
55 Medford Road
Staten Island, NY
Arnold Projansky
2 Cicero Ave.
New Paltz, NY
Eileen Fairbrother
4280 Stone Bridge Rd
Morrisville, NY
Giordana Grossi
12 Hudson St
Kingston, NY
Steven Jonas
105 Washington Ave.
Port Jefferson, NY
Roger Scott
1 North Pearl St
Buffalo, NY
Maureen Seymour
147 fish and game road
Worcester, New York
William Johnston
2438 Lucas tpk
High Falls, NY
kathryn condra
212 woodsome rd
babylon , ny
Lewis Ward
246 Smith Rd.
Newfield, New York
Michael Hartman
55 Bethune st #1011 NYC ny 10014
NYC, Ny
Elayne sears
384 Buck Mountain Rd
Crown Point, NY
Allison Jack
172 S. Applegate Rd. Apt. 5B
Ithaca, NY
Diane Bailey
1485 Fifth Avenue
New York, NY
Rosmina De La Cruz
7 Perry St. Apt. 1
Binghamton, NY
Wendy Roberts
118 East 93rd Street #9C
New York, NY
Kenneth Empey
635 Cullen Rd
Richfield Springs, NY
keith mccamy
404 Atlantic Ave
Greenport, NY
Mike Edelstein
14 Alice Court
E Rockaway, NY
Kathleenc Cronan
10 Rende Drive
Beacon, NY
Anna Carson
114 Shultz Dr. #6
Newfield, New York
H Mitchell Kawakami
364 State Street
Brooklyn, NY
Sam Lopopold
74 S Monsey
Airmont, NY
Nancy Pluta
40-12 217th Street
Bayside, NY
Giuseppe Luciani
87 Franklin Ave.
Brooklyn, NY
Gary Darden
191 St Nicholas Ave
New York, 10026
Leslie Pinilla
227 vanderbilt ave
SI, NY
Sandra Gasna
4400 Vestal Parkway E
Binghamton, NY
Celia Silbemran
185 Ashokan Road
Kingston, NY
Katherine Cooke
160 73rd St
Brooklyn, NY
Robes London
41 W 76th St, Apt. 3FD
New York, NY
Mike Hudak
38 Oliver Street
Binghamton, NY
Amy Harlib
212 West 22nd St. #2N
New York, NY
Kevin Finn
113 Division St
Sharon Springs, NY
Isabel Ron-Pedrique
135 William St. 4A
New York, NY
Calliope Spiliotis
54 Mill Pond Rd
Otisville, NY
Jessica Iankowitz
4400 Vestal Parkway E
Binghamton, NY
John Wolfe
359 54th Street
Brooklyn, New York
John Braungart
186 Springville Avenue
Amherst, NY
Susan Baker
39 Irving Place
Buffalo, NY
michael shelley
53 seacliff ave
miller place, ny
Neil Merrick
346 Baltic Street
Brooklyn, NY
Elizabeth Flax
329 Lewis Ave #2
Brooklyn, New York
Barbara Gautier
624 East 20 street
NY, NY
kevin roberts
653 allen st
stracuse, ny
Dana Drake
18 Horseshoe Lane
Warwick, ny
Jonathan Macy
127 Decker Ave.
Merrick, NY
alfonso fiero
8035 springfield blvd apt 6o
queens village, ny
Dennis Peeling
157 Symphony Ct
Eastport, NY
Myra Dremeaux
197 Forest DR
Mount Kisco, NY
Aleksandra Malamud
1167 Father Capodanno Blvd
Staten Island, NY
carrie salter
80 Metropolitan Avenue Apt. 2Q
Brooklyn, New York
Kevin Kitchen
1 North Pearl Street
Buffalo, New York
Alan Stein
7335 Utopia Pkwy.
Fresh Meadows, NY
Caroline Iosso
83 closter rd
Palisades , Ny
mary ellen pantaleo
7 black duck drive
center moriches, ny
mel berkowitz
21010 grand central parkway
jamaica, new york
Raymond Furniss
305 Chestnut Stredt
Oswego, New York
Claudia Lopez
393 S. 5th Street, Apt. 1
Brooklyn, NY
Rita Young
105 Seminary Ave
Binghamton, NY
Rick Snyder
75 Furman Cres.
Rochester, NY
Linda Rock
11376 County Road 16 Box 71
Dalton, New York
Nicole Klepper
8 Reynolds St Apt 8
Alfred, New York
Barbara Linsley
2910 Avery Rd
North Brookfield, NY
Jamie Randol
129 Millard Avenue
Bronxville, NY
jackie Weaver
116 Glen Avenue
Elmira, NY
Jim Allred
90 Dug Rd.
Accord, NY
Jessie Malecki
21 North St.
Schenectady, New York
Heather Lahman
60 Thatcher Road
Rochester, New York
Cahrles Hamilton
2 Kennedy Plaza Apt 901
Utica, NY
Greg Meola
151 weber lane
Olivebridge, Ny
GORDON FEAREY
20 WILLOW STREET
IRVINGTON, NY
Tiffany Matula
92 Gates Avenue
Brooklyn, NY
Kelly Voelger
10 McGregor Ct
Clifton Park, NY
rita herbst
367 hidden waters rd
margaretville, ny
Roger Jones
578 Engleville Rd
Sharon Springs, NY
Lynn Avedisian
2201 Seely Wood Rd
Walton, NY
kristin masters
1490 Betty Brook Rd.
South Kortright, NY
Quin Lin
100 Albert St.
Johnson City, NY
allen coulter
865 west end avenue, 6b
new york, ny
Robert Frederic Martin
317 West 89th Street -- 1FE
New York, NY
Bonnie Prosser
7974 Evans Rd
Holland Patent, NY
michel mazza
1840 stephen st
ridgewood, New York
stephen richards
405 elm st
fayetteville, NY
Kimbery Reinstein
4400 Vestal Parkway E
Binghamton, NY
Rosemary Jordan
40 East 9th St #10J
New York, NY
Audrey Gray
950 41st st
Brooklyn, NY
Russell Haynes
24 Mulberry St.
Clinton, NY
Stephen Engleman
125 Valley View Rd
Ithaca, NY
Renee Dwyer
3120 Amber Road
Marietta, NY
Tracy Schleyer
42 Antlers
Rochester, NY
JOAN MARDEN
13 KESSEL PK RD
KEESEVILLE, NY
Laurent Tetro
641 County Hwy 4
Unadilla, NY
Tolu Odansi
4400 Vestal Parkway E
Binghamton, NY
Sheila F Donnelly
94 Frazier Road
Garrison, NY
lila york
570 west end ave
new york, new york
Gail Jankus
Old Stone Hill Road
Pound Ridge, New York
Margaret DAuria
54 Grand Ave
Tappan, NY
Gordona L'Dera
287 E 139th St, #2
Bronx, NY
Tara O'Neill
100 Scribner Rd
Millerton, New York
Ed Malin
223 Maujer Street, #1A
Brooklyn, NY
Frankie DeMarco
241 Sixth Ave., #11C
New York, NY
Jennifer Miller
7757 Stone Road
Whitesboro, New York
Tanya Agathocleous
118 Bergen Street
Brooklyn, NY
Shira Margulies
22-68 35th Street
Astoria, NY
David Hermanns
354 Castleton Ave.
Staten Island, NY
Nancy Freshley
20 Felix Place
Amityville, NY
Eileen Driscoll
125 Valley View Rd
Ithaca, ny
Laurie Maoz
PO Box 189
Livingston Manor, NY
Yingxi Chen
4400 Vestal Parkway E
Binghamton, NY
Ellen Neal-Jones
578 Engleville Rd
Sharon Springs, NY
Lucinda Haag
3400 Brockport Spencerport Rd.
Spencerport, NY
John Malecki
307 E 10 St., Apt. 4
New York, NY
Massiel Armengot
22 North St. Apy. 11B
Binghamton, NY
Terri Schneider
151 Ridge Road
Valley Cottage, New York
Pam Kray Gallivan
60 E 8th Street 22E
New York, NY
John Gasior
40 Clinton Street
Mount Vernon, NY
Jessica Gusberg
1600 Caton Ave
Brooklyn, NY
Jules Gibbs
109 Haffenden Rd
Syracuse, NY
Tyrone Goddard
106 Easterly Terrace
Dewitt, NY
Stephen Auciello
96-15 Plattwood Ave
Ozone Park, NY
Elke Hallidy
PO Box 103 2139 Lakeview Lane
Skaneateles, NY
Joseph Gargiulo
226 Avenue Z
Brooklyn, NY
Rebecca Swinton
196 Twist Run Road
Endicott, NY
Alex Ellram
138 Riverview Road
Schoharie, NY
Julian Sedacca
18 wing lane
Wantagh, Ny
Karen Ouyang
30-32 Murray Lane
Flushing, NY
Susan Greenstein
424 John Joy Road
Woodstock, NY
carla giuffrida
40 woods rd
yulan, ny
Barbara Ruth
7471 East Bluff Dr
Penn Yan, NY
Jeff Wendler
10427 Ellis Rd
Saint Jacob, IL
Richard Chapman
70 Boot Hill CT
Amityville, NY
Pola Lem
17 Sound Beach Rd.
Bayville, NY
Matthew Grabosky
1630 Delphi Road
Cazenovia, New York
Philip Chadwick
1311 Jackson Ave. #6E
Long Island City, NY
Pam Spritzer
West End Avenue
New York, NY
Joan Anne Caron
1 Allman Pl
New Hartford, N.Y.
Alicia Cruz
400 East 52nd Street
New York, NY
Shawn Garrett
52 Prospect Ave.
Sea Cliff, NY
Mus Abdulkarim
4400 Vestal Parkway E
Binghamton, NY
Ken Kicak
132 Kennedy Drive
Horseheads, NY
Donna Henes
279 Sterling Place
Brooklyn, NY
brian greenberg
89 chelsea drive
mt.sinai, new york
Lisa DelSignore
273 Bennett Avenue, 7A
New York, NY
Sandy Russo
625 Greenwich Street
New York, NY
Jonathan Wyatt
23 Craft ave.
Glen Cove, New York
Judith Cantor
315 East 72nd St.
New York, NY
Nicholas Lee
152 Oak St.
Binghamton, NY
Robert RSanjour
944 President Street
Brooklyn, New York
Susan Hayward
776 Bronx River Rd
Bronxville, New York
Hubert Huang
180 Hawley St.
Binghamton, NY
John Owen
802 Merchants Rd
Rochester, NY
ruth gallo
240 waverly place #63
new york, new york
Delia Tolz
24 Ross Ave
Chestnut Ridge, NY
Theo Clark
1999 Burdett Avenue
Troy, New York
Stuart Weinberg
16 montrose road
Scarsdale, New York
Elizabeth Altemus
5991 South Hill Rd
Middlesex, NY
Lena Hong
4400 Vestal Parkway E
Binghamton, NY
Charles Paliocha
950 41st Street
Brooklyn, New York
Alice Lovely
457 W 57th St.
NYC, NY
Susan Mead
219 W. Lincoln St.
Ithaca, NY
Wendy DiMatteo
115 Richland St.
Rochester, NY
Sarah Timpson
45 Sutton Place South
New York, NY
david braucher
231 County Rt 52
greenwich, ny
David Hopkins
321 Roe Road = POB 156
Willseyville, NY
Anne Dooling
Geoge Street
Patchogue, New York
Patricia Amazalorso
12 Valerie Lane
Cortlandt Manor, NY
Chris Keil
99 Schubert St.
Binghamton, NY
Diane Katz
253 Upper Byrdcliffe Rd
Woodstock, NY
Matthew Cortese
714 S. Beech St., Apt. #1
Syracuse, NY
Jeremy Skipper
13 College Hill Rd. Apt 1
Clinton, NY
sarah westwind
5 abode rd
new lebanon, ny
Judith Wells
PO Box 72
Poyntelle, Nj
Peter Clark
MAD AS HELL AND I'M NOT GONNA TAKE IT ANYMORE!
Cooperstown, NY
Laura Chalfin
31 Main Street
Delhi, NY
Benedetto Puccio
PO Box 150
Spencertown, NY
Barbara Coon
3858 Rt. 28
Watkins Glen, NY
Madeline Kripke
155 Perry St. #7B
New York, New York
David Russo
17 foxcroft lane
Williamsville, Ny
Mark Goldfield
292 Park Place
Brooklyn, New York
Alex Halmen
250 Washington St.
Binghamton, NY
Michael Gelfer
345 Lake Shore Road
Putnam Valley, NY
Robert Schwartz
11 Miller Ter.
White Plains, NY
chuck dipietro
81 Pondfield Road
Bronxville, NYS
phyllis miyauchi
8 prospect st.
south glens falls, new york
Serra Borawski
Glen Ave
Port Chester, NY
Anne Lucas
18 Pine Ridge Road
Poughkeepsie, New York
Sara Sylvester
272 Fishkill Ave.
Beacon, NY
kathryn nocerino
139 w 19th St
new york, ny
Lydia Gyamioh
4400 Vestal Parkway E
Binghamton, NY
Keith Ford
P.O.Box 324
Amawalk, New York
Scott MacDougall
433 West 21st Street, Apt. 6F
New York, NY
Ajay Joshi
641 White Plains Rd
Binghamton, NY
Mark Siesel
163 Underhill Lane
Peekskill, New York
Deborah Levine
166 President Street, #3
Brooklyn, NY
Ruth Slater
1270 NorthAvenue
New Rochelle, NY
Charles Brobst
132 Hawley St Apt 2a
Binghamton, NY
Sarah Fargnoli
8 mt. Pleasant st.
Naples, NY
Michael Chung
4400 Vestal Parkway E
Binghamton, NY
Wendy Wheeler
PO Box 650
Honeoye, NY
Sophie Oberstein
272 West 107th, 6C
New York, New York
joel biazzo
110 larch street
cortlandt manor, new york
Tiffany Kopacz Johnson
59 Deer Trail
Chktg, ny
Miranda Alquist
234 Garfield Place
Brooklyn, NY
Marcia Sherwood
8 cedar st
Forestville, Ny
Elizabeth Terbrock
PO Box 311
Maryknoll, NY
Rodney Vane
9 Harvest Rd
Fairport, New York
Judy Coyne Becker
29 Breeman Street
Albany, NY
William Volcko
803 Crow Hill Rd
Skaneateles, NY
abby newton
PO Box 67
Shokan, NY
Carl Galyon
643 Vanderbilt Ave
Brooklyn, NY
David Kanowakeron Hill Morrison UE
P.O. Box 384
Ontario, New York
Lalita De Souza
155 West 60th Street APT 14H3
New York, New York
Glenn Smith
17 Richard Drive
West Nyack, NY
Christopher Quimi
36 Clarke St.
Binghamton, NY
Nancy Joniak
39 Jonathan
Amherst, NY
NANCY LIEBERT
304 MULBERRY ST
Rochester, NY
Evan Flury
61 Walnut
Binghamton, NY
Shannah Clarke
71-23 67th Place #2L
Glendale, NY
Erik Kihss
219-49 74th Avenue
Oakland Gardens, NY
Jan Tighe
187 Lake St
Pulaski, NY
Miltiade Delille
4400 Vestal Parkway E
Binghamton, NY
jose braconi
317 east 9th st
new york, NY
Lydia Miller
4408 Altschul
New York, New York
Pete Doherty
150 ocean ave
brooklyn, NY
Alden Burgess
700 4th Ave #2
Brooklyn, NY
alvin shoop
150 Bethlehem Rd
Callicoon Center, NY
Todd Rose
115 Marsh Rd
Ithaca, NY
Julie Nygren
15 Edgewood Road
Staten Island, New York
Sasha Powell
4400 Vestal Parkway E
Binghamton, NY
Zachary Loveless
18 furnace street
Norfolk, NY
Taeryn Kim
1230 York Ave, 4j
New York, NY
Marcia Ballard
5098 Lima Rd.
Geneseo, NY
Thomas Mallabar
7692 Old Floyd Road
Rome, NY
N. Dumser
313 Asharoken Ave.
Northport, NY
Anneth Delgado
4400 Vestal Parkway E
Binghamton, NY
Ellen Frieder
4 Twain Street
Baldwin, NY

Pages