You are here

Coalition Letter to Governor Cuomo Regarding Executive Order No. 41: Requiring Further Environmental Review of High-Volume Hydraulic Fracturing Combined With Horizontal Drilling

January 5, 2011

Honorable Andrew M. Cuomo
Governor, State of New York
The Capitol
Albany, NY 12224

Dear Governor Cuomo:

We, the undersigned, strongly support safeguarding the environment, public health and natural resources of the Catskills, Finger Lakes and Southern Tier regions that overlay New York’s Marcellus Shale formation, potentially the largest natural gas reservoir in America. That is why we write to thank you for your “continuation” of Executive Order No. 41: Requiring Further Environmental Review of High-Volume Hydraulic Fracturing Combined With Horizontal Drilling.

That order requires your Department of Environmental Conservation (DEC) to:

“complete its review of the public comments, make such revisions to the Draft SGEIS that are necessary to analyze comprehensively the environmental impacts associated with high-volume hydraulic fracturing combined with horizontal drilling, ensure that such impacts are appropriately avoided or mitigated consistent with the State Environmental Quality Review Act (SEQRA), other provisions of the Environmental Conservation Law and other laws, and ensures (stet) that adequate regulatory measures are identified to protect public health and the environment;”

More than 10,000 citizens, elected officials, business owners, environmental groups and students are signatories to a letter that requested Governor Paterson to withdraw the draft Supplemental Generic Environmental Impact Statement (draft SGEIS) due to its fundamental inadequacies and send it back to the drawing board. We are very grateful that Executive Order No. 41 requires DEC to address those shortcomings “comprehensively” before lifting New York’s de facto Marcellus Shale horizontal hydrofracking moratorium.


A 12/13/10 article in The New York Times underscores the flaws of the draft SGEIS proceeding. Then Acting DEC Commissioner, Peter Iwanowicz, reportedly said: “many of the comments have criticized the proposed standards for failing to adequately address issues like the cumulative impact of multiple drill sites, disposal of wastewater from the drilling and the protection of drinking water.”

DEC deliberately excluded a broad range of critical issues from the scope of the SGEIS proceeding by ignoring extensive testimony at its scoping hearings. Moreover, a great deal of new information has become available since the scoping process ended. Against that background and in order to fulfill the goals of Executive Order No. 41, we respectfully request that you require DEC to:

A) Convene a Citizens Advisory Committee as well as a separate Technical Advisory Committee to guide the agency in its decision-making. At a minimum, these committees should be comprised of representatives from: 1) local, state and federal government agencies involved with regulating Marcellus Shale gas matters; 2) local governments, the State Legislature and Congress; 3) the natural gas industry; 4) property owners who leased their mineral rights; 5) civic, environmental, public interest and good government groups; 6) concerned citizens; and 7) academic researchers.

B) Provide public notice and accept comments for no less than 30 days regarding how the agency can best fulfill the requirements of Executive Order No. 41; respond in writing to all comments before beginning the process of revising the draft SGEIS; and afford the public regular, on-going opportunities for participation and comment.

C) Adopt the following proposed policies:

  1. Discharges of natural gas flowback, drilling and production wastewaters must meet New York State’s GA (groundwater that supplies potable drinking water) effluent limitations when discharged into ground and surface waters or public and private treatment plants or re-used for hydraulic fracturing or injected into underground disposal wells. Natural gas wastewaters have been documented to contain high concentrations of Total Dissolved Solids (TDS), toxic chemicals and Technology Enhanced Naturally Occurring Radioactive Materials (TENORM). These persistent pollutants can contaminate groundwaters, “pass through” “secondary” wastewater treatment systems, concentrate in residual sludges and cause worker hazards.
  2. Marcellus Shale horizontal hydrofracturing must be regulated by Individual EIS proceedings instead of a Generic EIS. DEC proposed to require individual EIS reviews for the New York City and Syracuse watersheds, but not for the rest of the Marcellus Shale formation. Moreover, according to the draft SGEIS, “Flowback water recoveries reported from horizontal Marcellus wells in the northern tier of Pennsylvania range between 9 and 35 percent of the fracturing fluid pumped (emphasis added)” (Page 5-97.) Those meager recovery rates support the conclusion that horizontal hydrofracturing constitutes deep well injection of fluids that could threaten drinking water supply sources. DEC requires State Pollutant Discharge Elimination System (SPDES) permits for deep well injection of natural gas fluid. Those permits can only be granted on the basis of site-specific, individual EIS reviews.
  3. An investigation must be undertaken to determine whether the 1992 GEIS is sufficient to safeguard public health and if “No known instances of groundwater contamination have occurred from previous horizontal drilling or hydraulic fracturing projects in New York State.” (See: DEC Marcellus Shale homepage.)

    DEC concluded in its Final SGEIS Scope: “In the absence of a pattern of incidents that indicates a regulatory weakness or gap, the occurrence of isolated accidents or violations do not of themselves constitute reason to re-open the GEIS.” (See 8.3.2)

    DEC’s assertion is directly contradicted by hundreds of spills reported to the agency as well as additional information compiled by Chautauqua, Cattaraugus and Allegany County Health Departments. Those data were not provided to DEC during its scoping hearings.

    DEC’s investigation must include a review of the following information:

  4. DEC’s GEIS must be updated on a comprehensive basis. The U. S. Environmental Protection Agency wrote to DEC that its 1992 GEIS is out-of-date in so many respects that it should not serve as the basis for developing new horizontal hydrofracturing regulations. DEC must revise the GEIS to address all of the regulatory shortcomings identified by EPA, including: potential impacts to public health, water supply, water quality, wastewater treatment operations, local and regional air quality, management of naturally occurring radioactive materials and cumulative environmental impacts.



In conclusion, Executive Order No. 41 is an historic effort to require DEC to make sure that the environmental impacts associated with Marcellus Shale horizontal hydrofracturing are “appropriately avoided or mitigated” prior to the permitting of that activity. The actions we respectfully request you to undertake would help achieve that goal and serve as a model of effective government regulation for the nation as a whole.

Thank you very much for your consideration. Best of luck with your administration.

Very truly yours,

Total Signatory Count: 5254

jean Ann Marwick
Post Office Box 236
Mahopac, New York
Terrance Nwton
120 Einstein Loop
Bronx, New York
Daniel Schmitt
Citizens Concerned about Natural Gas Drilling
1178 Wood Road
Mansfield, Pa
Anne Riordan
18 Banks Road
Brooktondale, NY
William Young
226 Main St
Leominster, MA
Nancy Chismar
6 York Dr Apt 6A
Edison, NJ
Marsha Aronson
91 Coldenham Road
Walden, New York
Michael LoPinto
458 Yosef Drive
Boone, NC
Jelica Roland
Sv. Martin 64
Buzet, Croatia
Yury Khlynov
327 East 101 street apt 8E
New York, NY
Maura Pellettieri
Buffalo FrackAction
318 Normal Ave.
Buffalo, NY
Howard Kilik
15 Highland View Road
Mahopac, NY
Esther Zamora
15656 Sequoia Avenue
Hesperia, California
Robyn Taylor
140 W. State Street
ithaca, ny
Jim Semp
202 king rd
Ithaca, Ny
dave c
8801 westmoreland lane
minneapolis, mn
Samuel Gainfort
3330 State Highway 8
South New Berlin, New York
Michelle Minier
6176 Morrell Rd
Wolcott, NY
Stephen Nicklay
2609 Brookdale RD, #5
Moorhead, MN
Kenneth Bardin
233 Lakeview Road
Oswego, New York
Yolanda Tovar
210 Hampton Road
Ithaca, New York
William VanWart
367 Carlton Ave
carole schiffman
112 oak hill rd.
ithaca, ny
Julie Simmons-Lynch
116 Kelvin Place
Ithaca, NY
Rosie Shoemaker
701 Highland Rd
Ithaca, NY
Tanni Hall
5030 N Frontenac Rd
Trumansburg, NY
George Cannon
5030 N Frontenac Rd.
Trumansburg, NY
Jeff Luoma
132 S Danby Road
Willseyville, NY
Caitlin Baxter
Ithaca City School System
1083 Taughannock Blvd.
Ithaca, NY
Jamie Zervos
Ithaca City School System
215 King St.
Ithaca, NY
Marta Potter
Ithaca City School System
413 Willow Ave.
Ithaca, NY
Elizabeth Appleton
132 S. Danby Rd
Willseyville, NY
Jean Locey
1735 Ellis Hollow Rd
Ithaca, NY
Laura Heyman
200 Moore Avenue
Syracuse, NY
Debi Mohan
420 Eglinton Ave.
Miami, Florida
Peter Shoemaker
701 Highland Rd
ithaca, ny
Sandra Melville
374 Aldrich Rd.
Norwich, NY
Garth Melville
box 906
rye, NY
Danyel logeball
312 cayuga heights rd
ithaca, ny
Mary Alm
308 Mid Way
Newfield, NY
Elena Lavoie
35 Hemlock Drive
Greenfield Center, New York
Katya Boyle
Roaring Brook Farm
428 Briar Hill Road
Cooperstown, NY
Alison Cares Pritz
106 Brook Lane
Ithaca, N.Y.
Zachary Schwartzman
37 West 72nd St
New York, NY
Adam Kornfeld
3939 s 18th
Lincoln, Nebraska
Patricia smith
975 County Road 10A
Norwich,, New York
Cornelia Wathen
24 Woodland Road
Stone Ridge, NY
John Kimmerle
Chelsea Yacht Club
10 Rombout Ridge Rd
Poughkeepsie, New York
Dean Janoff
130 West 130th Street
New York, New York
frank bennek
118 East 4th St #10
ny, ny
Robert Frey
876 Palmer Avenue
Mamaroneck, NY
Julie Mech
Dalton School
108 East 89th Street
New york, NY
Janet Thomas
311 Cafferty Hill Road
Endicott, NY
judith stahl
123 Woodland Road
Stone Ridge, NY
Jared HOwe
71 W. 107th
New York, NY
Jayne Port
246 Smith Rd
Newfield, NY
Theresa F Alt
Democratic Socialists of America
206 Eddy St.
Ithaca, NY
Ann Ingleman
123 Thistle Lea
Wiliamsville, New York
Wayles Browne
206 Eddy St.
Ithaca, NY
Tycho Dan
726 Five Mile Dr.
Ithaca, NY
carmel rome
642 ringwood rd.
ithaca, ny
Corinna Morton
PO Box 2952
Salt Lake City, Utah
Gretchen Schauss
43 Lost Feather Dr
Fairport, NY
Martha Frommelt
308 Elmwood Ave.
Ithaca, NY
Lila Bluestone
375 Bonnie Brae Ave
Rochester, NY
Leon Zoghlin
New York State Academy of Family Practice
1132 WestAve.
Hilton, N.Y
Nancy Curnutt
5 Sutton Point
Pittsford, NY
Jennifer Fitzsimmons
700 Maple Drive
Webster, NY
Suzanne Montalbano
8 Faculty Lane
Farmingville, New York
Timothy Bael
Democratic Party
201 Oak Hill Road
Ithaca, NY
David Parker
8211 Hatcher Lake Road
Sherwood, AR
Alice Pascale
1281 Stillwater Drive
Miami Beach, FL
Dean Melville
374 Aldrich Road
Norwich, NY
Jeanette M. Brennan
8639 Canning Factory Road
Cassville, NY
Hali Snow
1503 South Ave
Rochester, NY
Isabelle Lorans
Harlem United
123 West 124 th St.
New York, NY
Meredith Dillon
United for Action
689 Fort Washington Ave
new York, NY
105 First Street
Ithaca, NY
Lisa Thier
po box 122
phoenicia, ny
Susan Holland
243 Union Center Road
Ulster Park, NY
Sheila Miller
20 Carlton Drive
Orchard Park, New York
Patricia Mericle
201 Park Pl.
Ithaca, NY
Kathleen O'Neil
533 Cayuga Heights Road
Ithaca, NY
Nathan Hilgartner
533 Cayuga Heights Rd
Ithaca, NY
Anya Gibian
1379 Coddington Rd
Brooktondale, NY
a catch
137 riverside dr
binghamton, ny
dan flerlage
881 Bostwick Road
Ithaca, NY
Kevin Hilgartner
533 Cayuga Heights Road
Ithaca, NY
Marian Lindberg
11 Whitney Lane, PO Box 761
Wainscott, NY
Jacob Morris-Knower
227 Ridgedale Road
Ithaca, NY
Kris Kohler
1718 Christian Hill Road
Franklin, NY
John Imes
2599 E. Lake Rd.
Skaneateles, NY
Cassidy Fisk
657 Sheffield rd.
Ithaca, NY
JF Godet-Calogeras
3629 Five Mile Road
Allegany, NY
Daniel Massangalo
692 Ridge Road
Horseheads, NY
Brenda Moody
121 Park Avenue
Binghamton, NY
Tom Jordan
24 Grand Street
Binghamton, NY
Douglas Gausman
719 Underwood Road
Vestal, NY
peter wiedmann
po box 6841
ithaca, nY
Nicole Clevenger
346 mt vernon ave
Rochester, NY
Darius Preikstas
110 Queen St.
Ithaca, N.Y.
Heriberto Rodriguez
533 County Highway 18
Norwich, NY
Lillian Constant
PO Box 335
Roscoe, NY
David Elder
2025 Owego Rd.
Vestal, NY
Charlie Moore
296 Bear Swamp
Chenango Forks, NY
Cole Webster
306 St. Lawrence Ave.
Buffalo, NY
Heather Rusnak
13883 Hoffman Rd
Springville, NY
Severin Drix
3515 School Street
Valois, NY
Pamela Drix
3515 School Street
Valois, NY
Monica Noh
Environment New York
219 withers street
brooklyn, ny
Melissa Dobson
Melissa Dobson PR & Marketing
43 Scotch Pine Lane
Erin, NY
Anthony Napoli
Annapolis Valley Chapter, Council of Canadians
15 Grandview Dr
Wolfville, Nova Scotia, Canada
Karen Seifert
448 Hines Road
Newfield, NY
Lainie Cooke
57 West 75th Street
New York, NY
jacquelyn bonomo
310 E 51 St new York, New York
new york, new york
Elsie Cushing
1497 Water Wells Rd.
Alfred Station, NY
Val Cushing
1497 Water Wells Rd.
Alfred Station, NY
diane cox
593 lever hill rd.
andover, ny
Eric Cushing
1511 Water Wells Rd.
Alfred Station, NY